Marwan Jabour Describes Life in CIA Black Sites

Yesterday I wrote about the new Human Rights Watch report on the missing CIA prisoners who were whisked off to secret prisons on Ghost Air.

Today, the Washington Post publishes its series of interviews with Marwan Jabour, a prisoner seized in 2004 who was released in 2006.

First note: Jabour, HRW and intelligence officials say the number of secret prisoners far exceed the 14 President Bush said were transferred to Guantanamo. HRW has 38 unaccounted for, an intelligence official says more than 60 were held.

On to Jabour's account of his detention and torture. First, there's the "villa at Islamabad."

In the week before his arrival, Jabour said, Pakistani intelligence officers had beaten, abused and burned him at a jailhouse in Lahore, where he was arrested. There two female American interrogators also questioned him and told him he would be rich if he cooperated and would vanish for life if he refused. He said he was later blindfolded and driven four hours north to the villa in a wealthy residential neighborhood.

The house in Islamabad, which U.S. intelligence officials say was jointly run by the CIA and Pakistani intelligence, had been outfitted with jail cells. When Jabour arrived, he saw as many as 20 other detainees, including the 16-year-old son of an Egyptian sheik, who had been captured in Pakistan. Dozens of al-Qaeda suspects swept up in the years after Sept. 11, 2001, have been through the house, according to accounts by former prisoners and U.S. intelligence officials with knowledge of the facility.

Jabour spent five weeks there, chained to a wall and prevented from sleeping more than a few hours at a time. He said he was beaten nightly by Pakistani guards after hours of questions from U.S. interrogators. Then he and others were whisked off to CIA-run sites. Some sites were in Eastern Europe; Jabour went to one in Afghanistan. Interrogators -- whom he described as Americans in their late 20s and early 30s -- told Jabour he would never see his three children again.

After his release, Jabour, a Palestinian, returned to his parents home in the Gaza strip.

Jabour acknowledged helping al-Qaeda and Taliban fighters who fled Afghanistan as the U.S. military hunted for the perpetrators of the Sept. 11 attacks....Using funds from al-Qaeda financiers, Jabour said, he arranged for food, medical treatment and travel documents for several dozen people and arranged for others, including two African men who fought for al-Qaeda, to slip out of Pakistan. He did not return to Afghanistan to fight, and he said he had no interest in attacking Americans.

Apparently, he was not believed to be a member of al-Qaida, just someone who was helping them in Afghanistan. While the Administration believed him to be "a bad guy," it won't say why he was released.

Jabour was taken from the Villa to a CIA black site. He describes his treatment:

Daily interrogations were conducted by a variety of Americans. Over two years, Jabour said he encountered about 45 interrogators, plus medical staff and psychologists. He was threatened with physical abuse but was never beaten.

Once, he was shown a small wooden crate his interrogators called a "dog box" and was told he would be put in it if he didn't cooperate. He was told that Khalid Sheik Mohammed, the suspected architect of the Sept. 11 attacks who was among the 14 moved to Guantanamo Bay last year, became cooperative after he had been put in the box. But Jabour said he was not subjected to the crate.

Jabour was eventually transferred to Jordanian and then Israeli custody.

The Israelis treated him better than his other captors, he said. They got Jabour his first lawyer, an Israeli Arab named Nizar Mahajna, who said in an interview that the Israelis had held Jabour in a prison near Haifa for two months. He was not mistreated, blindfolded or shackled, the lawyer said.

Israeli authorities had considered charging Jabour with fighting for an enemy of the Jewish state. But, Mahajna said, Jabour's training in Afghanistan had occurred more than eight years earlier, he was not a member of al-Qaeda and he had never lived in the Palestinian territories.

It was the Israelis who ultimately freed him.

The Israeli government dropped the case and transferred Jabour to Gaza. Prison guards drove him to the Erez border crossing between Israel and the Gaza Strip. "Good luck," one of them said to Jabour as he crossed into Gaza, where his parents awaited.

Harrowing story. How many of these men are there? President Bush needs to pony up the information. As HRW's Joanne Mariner says, :

Last September, President Bush announced that he had emptied out the CIA's prisons by sending 14 detainees to military custody at Guantanamo. He said nothing about what had happened to many other people who were believed to have been held by the CIA. By leaving their fate and whereabouts unknown, he displayed a callous disregard for their families, a contempt for human rights norms, and a blatant indifference to the moral standing of the United States.

< Fla. May Ban Use of Term "Illegal Alien" | Libby Jury Note Was About Matthew Cooper >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft

  • Display: Sort:
    Let him rot in a secret jail, E-x-c-e-l-l-e-n-t... (none / 0) (#1)
    by Torq88 on Thu Mar 01, 2007 at 12:12:39 PM EST
    So what if he rotted in jail he supported people who attacked our country and killed our people. He was essentially a terrorist supplier. I'm glad that he didn't like jail too.

    I wish there were more of these guys in secret jails getting some night stick therapy. Or better yet in unmarked graves...So what?

    What other treatment for these slime would a person recommend? The aim of his boss and probably him as well is to have a global muslim code of law extend over everyone. The crazies in this country that don't get this should travel a little more as I have and see this first hand.

    Oh yes and women, forget it. When these animals travel with their chattle, um I mean wives (usually multiple) internationally out of whatever stinking hole they come from. They wear American Urban clothes dressed like wannabe gangstas oogling and learing at anything in a skirt with their depressed wives following in burkkas. Oh yes and one thing will always be found on or with these guys when they are picked up is a stack of porn. How much more hypocrisy does anyone need???

    So before you flame me please be clear about what you are supporting. These people are zealots they have chosen an unrelenting hardline world view that doesn't see you as fully human. Their leadship winds these guys up and sends them out like cruise missles.

    Reasoning with these zealots is about as effective as reasoning with Stalin or Hitler in truth it is even less effective. The same nutbags are caught again and again in the field after being released the 1st time. They will not stop because this what they actually want to be doing. Unless you accept their leadership they will not relent.

    Women's rights under islamic law are non-existent in practice.

    For my part I think the Bush Administration has been way too light on these guys. Rather than shutting these prisons down we ought to be opening more. That is one of the few messages these terrorists understand.

    By the way America solved this problem in the Phillipines after the Spanish American War for quite a long time and I fully support employing the same successful tactis we used there.