home

Two Lives Lost

Update: More on juvenile Tate in the news today here and more thoughts below the fold.

******

At 4:00 am this morning, hours before he was to face U.S. District Court Judge Richard Matsch for sentencing in a fraud case, banker Edward P. Mattar, III took a sledge hammer and knocked out a window in his 27th floor apartment, two blocks from Denver’s federal courthouse, and jumped to his death.

A few hours later, 20 miles away in Golden, Colorado, 19-year-old Nathan Quinn Tate faced a state court judge for sentencing following a jury verdict of guilty of first degree murder. His defense to the killing of his friends’ father, who had surprised the pair during a burglary of the father’s residence, was insanity, but the jury didn’t accept that. Nathan Tate was 16 at the time of the murder. The Judge imposed the sentence required by law in Colorado for first degree murder: Life without the possibility of parole.

Two lives lost to the criminal justice system, one to suicide, one to a sentence of life in prison. Surely there must be a better way.

(cross-posted at 5280.com)

Update: Regarding Tate. Not having followed the case before, I'm now struck by these details. On his insanity defense:

Tate, who was taken from his abusive mother when he was 3 and spent the rest of his life in a series of social services placements and mental institutions, pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity....ate's severe mental illness caused caseworkers to terminate the adoption.

Doctors who cared for Tate over the years characterized him during the trial as the "craziest" child they had ever seen.

Tate was acquitted of first degree murder and convicted of felony murder. Sounds like the jury believed he wasn't the killer, the victim's son, who got a plea deal for 62 years in exchange for testifying against Tate, was the killer.

But in a letter to the Rocky Mountain News, Tate said that he defended himself with a shovel when Steven Fitzgerald began hitting him with a scooter. Tate said that Michael Fitzgerald insisted that no one would be home that day.

"I did what I had to do to protect myself from his dad," Tate said. "I feel badly for what happend (sic) that day. I wish it never happend. But I did the right thing. I protected myself from possibly being killed. I couldnt escape and I was traped (sic)."

The first-degree murder acquittal shows that the jury believed that Michael Fitzgerald, not Tate, caused his father's death, defense attorney Shawna Geiger said. Michael Fitzgerald is serving a 62-year prison sentence after pleading guilty to second-degree murder and testifying against Tate.

Two jurors later said they felt forced into convicting on felony murder by the other jurors.

The victim's widow (and mother of the kid who got the 62 year deal) is yelling about how the system protects the rights of defendants over victims. (See her statement at the end of the article.)

A life sentence without parole for a disturbed teen isn't enough for her? What does she want, life plus cancer? Is she also thinking her own son got off too lightly? I bet not.

But she's not the point of my post. The point is life without parole for juveniles in Colorado must be ended.

< Markos and Joe and Valerie Wilson on Bill Maher Now | Hollywood Writers Strike to Start Monday >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    not to be nit picky or anything, (none / 0) (#1)
    by cpinva on Sat Nov 03, 2007 at 09:05:48 AM EST
    but didn't they both kind of contribute? one committed fraud, probably harming lots of people, who entrusted him with their hard earned money. the other took someone else's life.

    both bear (bore?) significant responsibility for the positions they find (found) themselves in. the criminal justice system, with all its defects, didn't force either to commit the crimes they were found guilty of. while one could argue the relative merits of the sentences, let's not cast either as some kind of innocent sacrificial lamb, they aren't.