home

Truth Serum: Fact or Fiction?

The Washington Post has a historical review of truth serum. It concludes:

In the 21st century, however, the answer appears to be: No. There is no pharmaceutical compound today whose proven effect is the consistent or predictable enhancement of truth-telling.

It traces the modern day concept of truth serum to the drug scopalamine, and says:

The modern fascination with truth-eliciting drugs began in 1916 when an obstetrician named Robert House, practicing in a town outside Dallas named Ferris, saw a strange event during a home delivery.

The woman in labor was in a state of "twilight sleep" induced by scopolamine, a compound derived from the henbane plant that blocks the action of the neurotransmitter acetylcholine. House had asked her husband for a scale to weigh the newborn. The man looked for it and returned to the bedroom saying he could not find it, whereupon his wife, still under the anesthetic, told him exactly where it was.

House became convinced that scopolamine could make anyone answer a question truthfully, and he went on to promote its forensic use.

As a young lawyer, I was always intrigued with scopalamine because it had the same chemical formula as cocaine -- C17 H21 NO4. In the 70's, defense lawyers would argue that cocaine was mis-classified as a narcotic drug. Only one isomer of cocaine, the l isomer, was illegal. It's mirror image, the d isomer, we would argue, had no psychotropic properties, did not get you high and was not illegal.

But for one state case in Massachussetts, I don't know that any lawyer had success with the argument in the 70's. But scopalamine has fascinated me ever since. In 2003, it was thought to produce a date-rape drug effectt

So. Is scopalamine a truth serum? Interestingly, the Times reports the debate now has moved on to the hormone oxytocin.

< Kissinger: We Can't Win in Iraq | Monday Open Thread >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    huh? (none / 0) (#1)
    by cpinva on Mon Nov 20, 2006 at 07:38:39 AM EST
    because the woman told her husband exactly where to find the scale, this dr. thought it was a "truth" serum? holy cow batman! what, she would have lied to him, had she been perfectly sober?

    it's this kind of intense, thorough analytical research, that tends to give science a bad name at times. i would place this right up there with polygraphs, and reading head bumps, as far as sound science is concerned.

    that's the most inane story i've heard in a while. tell you what, that, a drink from the fountain of youth, plus $1.00, will get you a small coffee at mcd's. :)

    It's OXYTOCIN... (none / 0) (#2)
    by Deconstructionist on Mon Nov 20, 2006 at 07:50:03 AM EST
     not oxycontin (oxycodine) being researched as a potential "truth-serum." Oxytocin is a hormone and oxycodone is a synthetic opiate used for pain relief and commonly abused-- two entirely different drugs.

       I think, anectdotally, that many drugs may  lower inhibitions and make people more verbose for a variety of reasons but that isn't the same as making them incapable of being untruthful. Making people talk might have investigatory benefits but the idea that "credibility" ensuring drugs will be found seems science fiction.

     

    thanks (none / 0) (#4)
    by Jeralyn on Mon Nov 20, 2006 at 08:58:47 AM EST
    I corrected the post to read oxytocin.  

    Parent
    The Manchurian Veterans - LSD, mind control drugs. (none / 0) (#3)
    by avahome on Mon Nov 20, 2006 at 08:30:27 AM EST
    Funny, there's an article up about mind control drugs and testing......remember LSD?  

    http://scoop.epluribusmedia.org/story/2006/11/16/13342/421

    "But still overlooked are G.I.s who suffered severe damage from service to their country as human test experiments.  The tale of the uniformed guinea pigs who participated in America's Cold War mind control program is, perhaps, one of the most disturbing chapters in the history of the country that became the world's "sole superpower."

    I had never heard of these particular... (none / 0) (#5)
    by Bill Arnett on Mon Nov 20, 2006 at 01:24:54 PM EST
    ...so-called "truth serums", but I have always heard that the theory behind them was that a person could be made to hover on the very edge of conscienceless where, in an extremely relaxed state would be UNLIKELY to be able to process an evasive or dishonest answer. But I had never heard of any of the agents as being considered provably certain to work.

    Anecdotally: Our son was born by c-section (very stress-free, Friday, 1 p.m., be there; we were, our son was, everything went swimmingly), so naturally my wife had a spinal block and anesthetics administered. I was allowed to sit beside her, comfort her, talk, etc.

    When it came time to close, the anesthesiologist gave her a dose of another "truth serum", sodium pentathol, which apparently acts to totally whack out your timeframe so that the mother isn't aware of the long passage of time while every sponge, scalpel, cotton swab, etc. is retrieved, counted and recounted.

    In less than a minute my wife gazed up at me and asked, "You know, hon?"; "What, babe?"; "This is the BEST BUZZ I HAVE EVER HAD."

    The anesthesiologist almost fell off his stool laughing and the whole room cracked up. But there was no doubt in anyone's mind that she spoke the absolute truth!

    I didn't think (none / 0) (#6)
    by Che's Lounge on Mon Nov 20, 2006 at 10:24:00 PM EST
    that anyone used pentothal anymore. We use Versed, which also lowers inhibitory centers, til they doze off (it's called moderate sedation). One nice side effect of versed is a short term retrograde amnesia of any minor procedure that you perform while they're out. But there's a trick to it. Not relevant here.