home

Specter Introduces Guest Worker Bill

Sen. Arlen Specter has introduced a "guest worker" bill for immigrants that would allow many undocumented workers to legally remain in the U.S.

The draft circulated by the lawmaker, Senator Arlen Specter of Pennsylvania, would also authorize millions of illegal immigrants who arrived in this country before Jan. 4, 2004 to remain here indefinitely, along with their spouses and children, as long as they registered with the Department of Homeland Security, paid back taxes and remained law-abiding and employed, among other conditions.

The proposal would require employers to attest that they had tried to recruit American workers before bringing in additional foreigners from abroad and to pay prevailing wages. The plan would not place a restriction on the number of foreigners who could take part in the guest worker program. Those workers would not have the right to become permanent residents or citizens. The bill is silent on whether illegal immigrants already in this country should be accorded that opportunity.

Hearings on the bill may begin next week. It is a compromise measure, one intended by Specter to rally the Republicans who are on both sides of the issue.

With his draft, Mr. Specter was striving to reconcile the warring factions within his own party and address concerns raised by business leaders, labor officials and advocates for immigrants who have battled fiercely in recent months over the shape of a proposal that would radically reshape immigration policy and the workplace.

Instead of bringing harmony, the bill has engendered criticisms by all sides.

Advocates for immigrants said the plan failed to protect the rights of immigrant workers, who they argue deserve a clear path to citizenship. And the A.F.L.-C.I.O. warned that a guest worker program of unlimited scale would depress wages and working conditions while creating a perpetual underclass of foreign workers.

Here's the nitty-gritty:

Under Mr. Specter's proposal, the guest worker program would be open only to foreigners living outside the United States. Applicants would be sponsored by employers -- though they would be allowed to switch employers during their time here -- and would undergo background checks and medical screening. If approved, applicants would be allowed to bring their spouses and children to the United States.

Work permits would be granted for three years, after which the worker would have to return to his country for a year and apply again. The guest worker could then be authorized for a second and final work permit for three years.

Illegal immigrants who arrived in the United States after Jan. 4, 2004 could also participate in the guest worker program, but only if they returned home and applied from their countries.

Those illegal workers who arrived in this country before Jan. 4, 2004 could stay in this country indefinitely, provided that they underwent background checks and did not remain unemployed for 45 days or more.

The LA Times has more on the division among the GOP on immigration and Specter's bill.

< Fitzgerald Receives 250 Pages of Cheney Office E-mails | Paratrooper Porn >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    Re: Specter Introduces Guest Worker Bill (none / 0) (#1)
    by kdog on Sat Feb 25, 2006 at 09:26:42 AM EST
    I agree that the immigrant workers should have a way to become citizens. If the bill is worded as such that the immigrants would never be allowed to become citizens, the threat of a permanent underclass is real...and very uncool.

    Re: Specter Introduces Guest Worker Bill (none / 0) (#2)
    by Joe Bob on Sat Feb 25, 2006 at 05:59:31 PM EST
    The concept of tying one's residency/citizenship to one's employer is a recipe for the abuse of workers. Not that this doesn't happen already. Sorry, but I just can't get behind a bill like this. It's like H1-B visas on steroids and it sells working-class Americans down the river. It's hard enough for people with a high school education to get a living wage job. Making them compete with people who will happily work for minimum wage and no benefits is no way to help that.

    Re: Specter Introduces Guest Worker Bill (none / 0) (#3)
    by kdog on Sun Feb 26, 2006 at 06:56:50 AM EST
    God points Joe Bob. If the workers are allowed to get citizenship they could then organize for better wages and benefits. If they are simply "guest workers" and attempt to organize, they would get a one way ticket to Juarez from their employer. That is the anti-american way in my opinion.

    Re: Specter Introduces Guest Worker Bill (none / 0) (#4)
    by Talkleft Visitor on Sun Feb 26, 2006 at 06:55:24 PM EST
    This bill needs to be shot down for exactly what it is, another way to undercut the American Worker. I remember being out of work for over a year and hearing that folks with far less qualifications (H1-B1) were getting the jobs I was looking for. I created 2 resumes on the Internet. One in my name and the exact same resume with an Indian Name and the words H1-B1 in the personal section. Guess which resume got zip and which one had the corporate recruiters ringing the phone off the hook. Totally Disgusting!