home

AARP Not Endorsing Any Specific Health Care Plan

AARP CEO Barry Rand released a statement today on why AARP supports a new health care plan:

Doing nothing is not an option. But any reform must not get between a patient and their doctor. It must not cut Medicare benefits. It must not allow insurers to continue to line their pockets by covering only the healthiest and the youngest.

And those 50 - 60,000 members who quit since July 1? AARP says almost 1.8 million people have joined or renewed their memberships in the same period. AARP has 40 million members.

So, does AARP support Obama's health care bill as he said last week? It's not clear. After Obama made the comment, it responded:[More...]

“While the President was correct that AARP will not endorse a health care reform bill that would reduce Medicare benefits, indications that we have endorsed any of the major health care reform bills currently under consideration in Congress are inaccurate.”

AARP says it is committed to making sure health care reform will do the following for members:

  • Lower Drug Costs and Strengthen Medicare: Close the Medicare Part D "doughnut hole," ensure patients' access to their doctors, and crack down on fraud and wasteful spending;
  • Protect Your Health Care Choices: Make sure you can choose your doctor, your health insurance plan and where to receive care;
  • End Discrimination by Insurance Companies: Prevent insurance companies from denying you coverage because of a pre-existing condition or using age to price Americans age 50-64 out of affordable, quality health insurance; and
  • Guarantee Stable, Affordable Coverage: Ensure you have the security of knowing that if you lose or change jobs, you will be able to get affordable, quality health insurance.

NBC News is releasing a new poll today showing "a plurality of Americans now oppose a government-run plan — 47 percent to 43 percent That’s a shift from last month’s poll (released in conjunction with The Wall Street Journal) when 46 percent said they supported it, compared to 44 percent who did not.

The poll finds support decreasing among seniors:

Among seniors eligible for Medicare the drop was even more striking — 10.4 points — suggesting the health care debate is raising alarm bells for older people.

How will it end?

In the House, where Democrats hold a 256-178 majority, passage of legislation will hinge on the ability of the administration and Democratic leaders to satisfy liberals who favor a robust government option and centrists who prefer the co-op approach.

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi is not insisting on a public option:

In a statement, Speaker Nancy Pelosi said, "There is strong support in the House for a public option," adding it is the best way "to lower costs, improve the quality of health care, ensure choice and expand coverage." But the statement did not rule out legislation that lacks a government option.

< Sen. Feingold: Won't Support Health Care Bill Without Public Option | DOJ Files DOMA Brief: Law Bad, But Must Be Enforced >
  • Premium Ads

  • Blog Ads

  • Contribute To TalkLeft

    donate to TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    Left-leaning AARP members were PISSED when AARP... (5.00 / 1) (#1)
    by JoeCHI on Tue Aug 18, 2009 at 01:51:26 PM EST
    ...endorsed Bush's Medicare Part D.  

    Perhaps they've decided that it's better to stay out of the endorsement business.

    AARP put out a similar statement... (5.00 / 2) (#2)
    by rdandrea on Tue Aug 18, 2009 at 02:31:33 PM EST
    After the Portsmouth meeting saying they hadn't endorsed any specific bill or plan.

    Obama dialed back the AARP "endorsement" language in the Montana and Colorado town halls to say only that they were endorsing reform.

    Although I'm an AARP member, I haven't considered them an advocate for seniors in a long time.  They're more into selling insurance.  I'm surprised they are on board with any reform at all, even conceptual.

    I had a long conversation with one of my (2.00 / 1) (#4)
    by jimakaPPJ on Tue Aug 18, 2009 at 04:13:16 PM EST
    states Directors for AARP...

    According to her AARP has not endorsed any plan.

    She was concerned over the losses but made the same point about new members. When I asked her for timing... how many new before Obama claimed and then after vs the losses she couldn't answer it but she acknowledged my point.

    The AARP set up a teleconference yesterday for my Congress critter....Before I got to the state Director a young lady answered by question as to why I had not been notified by saying it was for people between 50 and 64..... When I pointed out that this was obvious age discrimination and that I would speaking to the whatever is the proper authority to file a complaint the Director was an unhappy camper.

    It is obvious that the teleconference was meant to screen out anyone on Medicare who might be concerned over rationing and this anti-reform, or at least "this" reform.

    You could have turned around (5.00 / 3) (#5)
    by Cream City on Tue Aug 18, 2009 at 04:58:15 PM EST
    your collar and asked to be in on the Obama "faith teleconference" on health care today.  Anyone heard anything about it?

    To the point:  Good for you for giving AARP grief for segmenting us by age.  If we aren't all in this together, the ship of state sinks even faster.

    [ Parent ]

    Bump and update. (2.00 / 1) (#6)
    by jimakaPPJ on Tue Aug 18, 2009 at 07:03:31 PM EST
    Bump and update. My daughter tells me that yesterday around 7PM a call came in from the AARP but things were so screwed up on how to ask a question she hung up. (I wasn't home and she forgot to mention it.)

    So the question is, since I am not between 50 and 64 and since my daughter is not either, why was I told that was the selection criteria?

    Or does this just prove that being incapable of following the plan excuses you from coming up with the plan?

    [ Parent ]

    Put your guns in the Marshals office (none / 0) (#3)
    by joze46 on Tue Aug 18, 2009 at 03:48:01 PM EST
    It Always troubled me when an Insurance Company like AARP considers itself a not for profit organization, yet will not take a leadership roll in announcing the support of a new Health Care proposal that shapes our future or could possibly be  crafted to something to benefit everyone.  

    Worse and I think very true I found out this AARP supported the Bush prescription drug plan which is definitely a controversy of an unfunded legislation that is totally under reported in this confusion. Plus, adds to the deficit or poor Judgement in creating something for everyone that was screwed up from the getgo. From that view AARP is of poor value as a progressive entity. And certainly with out a doubt not conservative to promote legislation without proper funding. That's nuts. The more I watch the news the more I think the Mainstream Media is complicit in this confusion to encourage the failure of health care reform.

    Its easy for any Company to say one thing on the fly, like giving Obama the impression AARP supports the new health care proposal, but genuinely behind the scenes and when necessary steps to the sidelines and goes foul. For all its worth what is really happening before our eyes, the inner true Conservative Democrats are in a real battle. No, Obama is not lying. He is witness to all sort of mind changing or political position jockey juxtaposing, finding this political hoop ball fix is a harder than he thought. Everybody is not playing hard ball they are playing for keeps.    

    Though, America has a huge legion of Republicans that Parade around as Democrats, coined today as Blue Dog types, a name that I personally would like see removed as much as the word nigger has been removed from conversations and debate in passing. Sorry but personally think the Dog language begs the question all the time and we all wind up in a vicious circular vile smearing streaming videos diminishing time wasting rhetoric. It's powerful and has the punch to kill this whole thing and the media knows it. And uses it "at will".

    Did you ever notice how at one moment in a debate, especially many Republicans and Fox news freaks can say America is considered the best country, the most powerful, ever in recorded history? Sometimes Hannity or Huckabee makes me feel like we all walk on water. Then at the drop of a hat proclaim in the highest order that our government is the problem, per Ronald Reagan, or Sean Hannity and others. The government can not be trusted. The government does not do anything good. At the same time a Senator likes Grassley "goes out right in spoken plain English" to say our government is a predator. Sheesh, does Grassley know how much he is taking about himself and the work they do in Congress and the Senate. Grassley is so dysfunctional it amazes me that we get anything done.

    Ladies and Gentleman of America the whole simple concept of choice in Health Care Option by the people seems to be in the balance. A very clever yet very obvious notion which to me is lame to state a little clause or paragraph or a statement  of sort proclaim " The Public Option" is going to be left out.

    My goodness,  this whole thing is basically a public option. If you don't want it fine... but don't come to a meeting from across the country packing a loaded weapon to yell and confuse my town hall. That action, boarders on sedition, here to me Sedition includes subversion of a Constitution, my right to assemble peaceably, but being armed with a weapon shows the "at will" in the business of assault with incitement of discontent (or of resistance) to lawful local authority by show of personal arms weapons.

    So what does it come down to? We have to have the town Marshal Wyatt Earp come and say " O.K cowboy put your guns in the Marshals office and pick them up after the meeting."