Tuesday Afternoon Open Thread
I'm going to share my thoughts with you on something almost none of you care about -- should Joe Girardi have started A.J. Burnett on short rest last night? I actually told my father before the game that I would have held Burnett back for Game 6 because he was better at Yankee Stadium than on the road (Burnett had a good history starting with 3 days rest.) So I am doing an "I told you so" now? No. Thinking about it, I was wrong and Girardi was right. [More...]
Why? Because A.J. Burnett was more than capable of giving up 6 runs in 2+ innings on regular rest, with extra rest, with no rest, on the road, at Yankee Stadium, etc. In short, you never have a clue what Burnett will do in any particular start. Girardi was right to use him against Cliff Lee. If Burnett had one of his good nights, then you would have a chance against a sharp Lee. If Lee was off, then a good Burnett would beat him. You were going to start Burnett in one of the last 3 anyway and a Burnett start was always going to be a roll of the dice. Might as well roll them in Game 5 against Cliff Lee. Now you have Andy Petitte, who will almost certainly give you a chance to win in Game 6, and C.C. Sabathia, who will almost certainly give you a chance to win a Game 7. Not pitching Burnett in Game 5 would have meant Gaudin vs. Lee, an improbable matchup for the Yankees, Burnett in Game 6, a crap shoot, and Sabathia in Game 7. Girardi made the right decision.
This is an Open Thread.
| < Steeped In Village Think | Election Night > |





