Illogic On NATO And Georgia
I always thought Roger Cohen was not the sharpest knife in the drawer and this column on NATO, Georgia and the Ukraine proves it. Interestingly, Cohen starts well:
In retrospect the NATO summit declaration of April 3 about Georgia and Ukraine seems almost criminal in its irresponsibility: “We agreed today that these countries will become members of NATO.” That lofty commitment emerged from a Bucharest meeting so split over the two countries’ aspirations to enter the Atlantic alliance that it could not even agree to offer the first step toward joining, the Membership Action Plan that prepares nations for NATO.
(Emphasis supplied.) Absolutely. So what does Cohen suggest NATO do?
at the NATO foreign ministers’ meeting in December, it should replace Bucharest blather with basics: a Membership Action Plan for Georgia and Ukraine.
Say what? To coin a phrase, that would be "criminal irresponsibility." Does Cohen think we do not have enough wars to fight right now? More . . .
Why should NATO NOT set out a MAP for the Ukraine and Georgia?
It is unconscionable to declare objectives for which the means do not exist, and to paper over European-American division through statements of ringing but empty principle. The history of the so-called “safe areas” in Bosnia, Srebrenica among them, is sufficient testimony to the bloodshed lurking in loose commitments.
That’s a cautionary tale for Monday’s European Union summit on the Georgian crisis: no empty commitments, please, and no feel-good doling-out of threats or sanctions against Russia for which the will and means are lacking. Grandstanding has had its day.
Yes, I am quoting Cohen's own column. A MAP for the Ukraine and Georgia would be grandstanding. No one in Europe or the US is going to war to defend Georgia's territorial claims. And yet Cohen is arguing that NATO signal its willingness to do just that in an act of empty grandstanding. This could provoke Russia to preemptively attack Georgia BEFORE it becomes a member of NATO. Cohen's advice is insane by his own column's argument.
You know when Georgia and the Ukraine should get MAPS? The day after Russia accepts one. And NOT a day before.
Speaking for me only
| < Obama Plays Poker? McCain Draws New Cards | Wolfson For Obama > |





