home

Newsweek Examines Eliot Spitzer's Life

In a very long article, Evan Thomas examines the life and background of Eliot Spitzer, trying to understand why he engaged in such reckless conduct. Shorter version: He was trying to please Daddy.

He describes Spitzer's family:

Brought up in a cold-water flat in a New York slum, Eliot's father, Bernard, the son of Jewish immigrants, made a half-billion dollars in the cutthroat world of New York real estate. He and his wife, Anne, a former college literature teacher, are regarded as refined and cultivated, not domineering. But expectations in the Spitzer household in Fieldston, a wealthy enclave of the Bronx, were extremely high.

A series of Eliot's childhood and college friends have reported the intimidation they felt just sitting at the Spitzer dinner table. Each of the three Spitzer children was required to hold forth and debate on worthy topics (social chitchat was frowned upon). Jason Brown, who went to Horace Mann School, Princeton and Harvard Law with Eliot, compares the dinners to "a college class where the professor grills you." Afterward came games of Monopoly that qualified as play only in the loosest sense. "I play to kill," Bernard liked to joke.

More...

Eliot the student:

The Spitzer children never rebelled. His older brother, Daniel, became a neurosurgeon. His sister, Emily, became a successful public-interest lawyer. Eliot never stopped climbing the Meritocrat Ziggurat. At Horace Mann, an incubator of competitiveness, he carried not the usual backpack but a hard briefcase, along with copies of foreign-policy magazines (to bone up for dinner). Rejected at Harvard, his aspiration, Eliot had to settle for Princeton, but got back on track by gaining admission to Harvard Law and making the Law Review. At Princeton, he was politically active, but while other students marched in protest, Eliot played squash with the university president, William Bowen. In the library, young Spitzer was known as "Ironbutt" for his prodigious study habits.

On the financing of campaigns for Attorney General:

But Spitzer was not out of his father's shadow (or debt) when he ran for office. Spitzer at first concealed, then belatedly admitted, that his father had advanced several million dollars (hidden as forgiven loans) to finance his two runs for New York state attorney general.

Spitzer's first scandal while Governor, TrooperGate:

Spitzer almost immediately got into a feud with one of the toughest bosses, the Senate majority leader, Republican Joe Bruno. Bruno called Spitzer an "overgrown, rich spoiled brat who has tantrums all over the place." Spitzer may or may not have referred to Bruno as a "senile piece of s––t," as widely reported, but he definitely told the Assembly Republican leader, James Tedisco, "I'm a f–––ing steamroller and I'll roll over you." Before long, Spitzer was embroiled in a classic Albany scandal known as "Troopergate." Spitzer's aides were caught siccing the State Police on Bruno, trying to catch him using the state helicopter for fund-raising trips. Unconvincingly, Spitzer insisted he was not directly involved (an investigation of the incident cast blame on Spitzer without finding that he broke any laws).

After that, Newsweek reports, Eliot began to slide downhill:

The tabloids were jeering at "Eliot Mess," and even his defenders at The New York Times had grown chilly. The Great Crusader had been dragged down into the pits of Albany politics. This was about the time Spitzer began aping the sort of lowlifes he despised. He began consorting with prostitutes.

The article concludes with some psychobabble:

The question is whether Spitzer can change. All his life, he has sought to match—or exceed—the expectations set for him. In psychological terms, his narcissistic disorder has finally caught up with him; his grandiosity has been deflated. Put more simply, this would be a good time to start thinking about how he could do something he really wants to do that is less grand but honorable and serves the public.

I don't think Eliot's upbringing was a huge factor in his spectacular lapse of judgment. If it was, we would have seen it before and there wouldn't have been such a unanimous reaction by everyone who knew him that they were completely shocked to learn of it.

I find it more likely he got drunk with the power of being Governor and thought he was invincible. Today he knows differently. It's just too easy to blame the parents.

I hope no criminal charges are brought against him. He needs no more punishment than what was inflicted on him this week. His wife and children have been through enough.

I also suspect it's the support of his parents, not just his siblings, wife and children that are sustaining him right now and he's very grateful for it. He should be.

< The Wrong Defense | This Is Funny >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    Yeah, I'm at a loss (5.00 / 1) (#1)
    by Deconstructionist on Sun Mar 16, 2008 at 03:15:46 PM EST
     as to why a demanding or even domineering father would be cause to procure hookers as a 48 year old.

      It might be a reason to do things to make people think you are not likely to procure hookers but I see no correlation to the actual act of doing it.

      On the other hand, I don't think being intoxicated by power or a sense of invulnerability explains it either. That soertof assumes it is natural to want to do it and the only reason men don't is feelings of lack of power or fear of being caught. We're not all that bad.

    Sort of a side note (5.00 / 2) (#2)
    by shoephone on Sun Mar 16, 2008 at 03:25:05 PM EST
    This confused me a bit:

    At Princeton, he was politically active, but while other students marched in protest, Eliot played squash with the university president, William Bowen.

    Spitzer and I are the same age (48) and attended college during the same years. Yes, Reagan was a nightmare for the middle class, but I don't recall any protests at all in those years except for a few smatterings of protests against U.S. involvement in Central America. And I went to a very liberal UC.


    A Wiki list of the Protest Washington DC marches (none / 0) (#26)
    by ding7777 on Sun Mar 16, 2008 at 07:11:20 PM EST
    September 19, 1981, Solidarity Day march. AFL-CIO organized march to protest Reagan Administration labor and domestic policies. 260,000 march.

    November 27, 1982 - Washington Anti-Klan protest

    March 1 to November 15, 1986 - The Great Peace March for Global Nuclear Disarmament. From Los Angeles, California to Washington D.C. (a.k.a. The Great Peace March) to raise awareness of the growing danger of nuclear proliferation and to advocate for complete, verifiable elimination of nuclear weapons from the earth.

    October 11, 1987 - Second National March on Washington for Lesbian and Gay Rights. The second such march on Washington drew 500,000 gay men and women to protest for equal civil rights and to demand government action in the fight against AIDS.



    Parent
    All of them after Spitzer graduated (none / 0) (#27)
    by scribe on Sun Mar 16, 2008 at 07:35:56 PM EST
    from Princeton, and some even after he'd graduated from law school.

    QED.

    Parent