home

Lose Moral Legitimacy, Lose The War

The Senate recently passed a bill recently that would have restricted the CIA to using those interrogation methods listed in the Army Field Manual. In other words, it would bar the CIA from employing so-called "enhanced interrogation" techniques such as waterboarding.  Of course President Bush is planning to veto this legislation.  

The Field Manual states that "Abuse of detained personas is immoral, illegal, and unprofessional. . . Torture and cruel, inhuman, and degrading treatment is never a morally permissible option, even if lives depend on gaining information. . ."

In addition to morality and legality, the Field Manual also provides another reason that for opposing torture and abused of suspected insurgents.  It is the historical example of the use of torture during the Algerian war of independence by the French military.  I think the title of this section says it all, "Lose Moral Legitimacy, Lose the War". The "failure to comply with moral and legal restrictions severely undermined French efforts and contributed to their loss despite several significant military victories."  The use of torture undermined the French governments moral authority and "empowered the moral legitimacy of the opposition".  Finally the use of torture "degraded the ethical climate throughout the French Army.  

Lose moral legitimacy, lose the war.  I would think that doing what is moral should be justification in itself but for those who do not think this is a sufficient reason not to torture the Army Field Manual provides another reason.  We will lose the war.  Perhaps when you consider all the moral stains to our country's honor that have occurred under the Bush administration (Abu Ghraib, Haditha, Black Water, etc.) maybe the war has long been lost.  Our betrayal of our values makes us weaker instead of stronger.  So why does President Bush want to veto these restrictions on "enhanced interrogation" techniques?  

< Grand Theft Auto Kids mow down Soccer Moms | The Brattleboro, VT indictment resolution: Why is it legal nonsense? >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    The moralty of war..or (none / 0) (#1)
    by FlaDemFem on Mon Mar 24, 2008 at 09:15:03 AM EST
    the morality of torture, now there are a pair of prime oxymorons. There is no morality in war, or in torture. Why people keep pretending there is is a mystery. War and torture are immoral, and nothing you can say will change that. Moral legitimacy cannot be an issue for things that are immoral.