home

Saturday Nights With Cops

In his ode to the television series Cops, Ken Tucker asks:

I do like it when some bad guy makes a violent move and a billyclub must be applied with quick force. Does this make me a bad person?

Maybe not, but the guilty pleasure of seeing the bad guy get smacked depends on the belief that the smackee deserves it. The footage shot for the Cops series is heavily edited to make the police look good (police departments wouldn't cooperate with the filming if that were not the case), depriving viewers of a realistic basis for deciding whether the violence was necessary or contrived for the camera. A better question would have been:

Has television, with hundreds of thousands of highly dramatic pictures in reports celebrating the use of force by police officers, helped create a mindset among police officers and others that excessive force is okay?

Glamorizing police violence might make for good ratings, but how many viewers understand that the worst scenes of unnecessary or excessive violence rarely make it to their TV screens?

< Saturday Open Thread | The Scrushy Squeeze >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    Off-script? (5.00 / 1) (#1)
    by Ben Masel on Sat Dec 27, 2008 at 02:05:44 PM EST
    A few years back "COPS" announced they'd be filming with the Madison Police dept. I prepared to follow them with my "I do not Consent to a Search" T-shirt and cards, advising the unpaid "extras." Perhaps I gossiped too much, the filming here was soon cancelled.

    Bad Boy Bad Boy (5.00 / 1) (#7)
    by SOS on Sat Dec 27, 2008 at 04:34:20 PM EST
    Bread and circuses. Low-cost, low-quality, high-availability food and entertainment that have become the sole concern of the People, to the exclusion of matters that others consider more important: e.g. the Arts, public works projects, human rights, or democracy itself.

    What you gonna' do when they come for you

    Albuquerque Used To Be (none / 0) (#2)
    by tokin librul on Sat Dec 27, 2008 at 02:23:27 PM EST
    a major place where "COPS" was shot.

    Abq cops have a LONG history of excessive violence in apprehending and detaining persons of certain 'classes.'

    It's a bourgeoise town...

    Ooops an extra 'e' (none / 0) (#3)
    by tokin librul on Sat Dec 27, 2008 at 02:24:47 PM EST
    "bourgeois"  

    Parent
    I find this show offensive on so many levels. (none / 0) (#4)
    by mexboy on Sat Dec 27, 2008 at 03:28:04 PM EST
    Putting people on TV, who may or may not have committed crimes, and against their will, for the entertainment of the general public, does not speak well of our humanity.

    I refuse to be part of it.

    I watched it once (none / 0) (#8)
    by MoveThatBus on Sat Dec 27, 2008 at 05:14:22 PM EST
    and have to agree completely with you. I doubt the public writes to the networks and asks for these types of shows. But, they respond to what the networks decide they might flock to. These are inexpensive programs to put on...no script writers, rehearsals, sets or stars to cost huge sums in production.

    Worse than Cops, though, was that entrapment program Dateline: To Catch a Predator. I could hardly believe more than one episode of that program made it to the air.
     

    Parent

    I never watched that show either (none / 0) (#11)
    by mexboy on Sun Dec 28, 2008 at 05:26:57 AM EST
    Cops should be catching criminals, not fabricating them.

    Parent
    Bashing cops is just a distraction (none / 0) (#5)
    by Jacob Freeze on Sat Dec 27, 2008 at 03:36:11 PM EST
    IMHO based on thousands of hours photographing all kinds of people on the street, night and day, there is no race and no class and no demographic that isn't safer when police appear than otherwise. This is especially true for black people, and even more particularly for young black males.

    About 4000 black teenagers like Jamiel Shaw Jr. are killed by guns every year in the United States, and the number of them that are killed by police is infinitesimal in comparison to the number killed by other young men almost exactly like themselves.

    I have seen about a dozen serious physical fights on the street in my life, and some of them led to shooting, but I never saw a fight or heard shots fired when the police were in sight, however distantly.

    This doesn't mean that I haven't personally been harassed by police more than virtually anybody who chimes in with the usual chorus whenever some episode of police brutality appears in the news.  Most policemen have no idea about the extraordinary First Amendment protection of art photographers like me, and dozens of policemen have tried to push me off my spot. But I never  moved, and they never assaulted me.

    It's an entirely different story with private security guards, who typically believe that the property rights of whoever hires them extend onto the sidewalk and street, and the First Amendment doesn't protect me from those guys.

    That's when I rely on having a 60-inch steel monopod in one hand, and a can of hideously intense (5.3 million SHU) pepper-spray in the other.

    Bring it on!

    On the street, square-headed white people habitually ask me if I'm afraid of the black kids, and hip white people ask me if I'm afraid of the police.

    No, and no, for different reasons, but nobody ever asks me about the really scary demographics: security guards and skin-heads.

    er (3.00 / 2) (#6)
    by Nasarius on Sat Dec 27, 2008 at 04:20:27 PM EST
    What you're saying is entirely beside the point of anything TChris has written here. Police brutality does exist, it is a problem, even if you don't have any direct anecdotal experience with it.

    I don't think anyone's disputing that a police force is a necessary and good thing. I say fund them well, train them well, encourage them to focus directly on actual violent and harmful crime, but also provide independent oversight and real consequences for abuse of power.

    It's a bit like Abu Ghraib, when conservatives were screeching about how Saddam Hussein and al Qaeda are so much worse. Well yes, but we expect that, just as we all agree that violent criminals are bad. We just expect better from the military and police, because we expect them to be on our side and do good, and we're justifiably outraged when they're not.

    Parent

    "er" (none / 0) (#9)
    by Jacob Freeze on Sat Dec 27, 2008 at 06:38:17 PM EST
    Anything anyone with actual experience on the street in black neighborhoods has to say is obviously "beside the point" for teen-age brains that just want to bash the police for statistically insignificant episodes of "police brutality."

    What else is also "beside the point?"

    How many times have you seen the Rodney King video?

    How many times have you read about Rodney King?

    And how many times have you heard the names of anyone who died during the Rodney King riots?

    How about Arturo Carlos Miranda?

    Miranda, a 23-year-old Mexican-American, was driving home from a South-Central park with a nephew and a friend. A blue car pulled up and someone fired one shot, hitting Miranda in the chest.

    "Beside the point."

    How about Dwight Taylor?

    Taylor, a 43-year-old African-American, stood on a South L.A. street, where he had stopped on his way home from work. Someone drove by and shot him in the neck.

    "Beside the point."

    Did you ever hear of Eduardo Canedo Vela?

    Car trouble led to the death of Vela, a 33-year-old Mexican-American from Arvin, who was driving with two friends when their car broke down on Slauson Avenue. Vela stayed with the light-blue, 1986 Ford Taurus, while his companions looked for a phone. When they returned, Vela was on his back in the street, with a gunshot wound to the chest. Vela left behind a wife, Rosa, and an 8-month-old daughter.

    "Beside the point."

    Did you ever hear of Anthony Lamarr Netherly?

    A passing motorist found Netherly, a 21-year-old African-American, lying in the street and took him to Martin Luther King Jr. Medical Center. He had been shot in the left eye. Netherly was a nurse's assistant.

    "Beside the point."

    John Henry Willers?

    It appears that this man's kindness cost him his life. Thirty-seven-year-old Willers, a white man from Salt Lake City, tried to help people involved in a head-on collision in Mission Hills. Passersby gunned him down, the fatal shot piercing his heart.

    Nissar Daoud Mustafa?

    Arsonists torched the J.J. Newberry Department store on South Western Avenue. Nearly four months later, on August 12, a worker found the body of Mustafa, a 20-year-old Indian or Middle Easterner, in the rubble. Mustafa had lived at 326 S. Normandie Ave. in the Wilshire District.

    Elias Garcia Rivera?

    Hours after the jury verdict, a group of African-American men stood outside their North Hollywood apartment collecting donations to retry the white officers. One resident gave $2 and resisted demands to give more. He tried to run away but was hit on the head with a board. His neighbor, Rivera, intervened and was struck in the head, suffering a broken skull. He went into a coma, and his family removed him from life-support on December 16. A jury convicted Traville Craig, 19, of murder, and he received a life sentence with no chance of parole.

    Ira Frederick McCurry?

    McCurry, a 45-year-old white male, was found dead on the street, shot through the right eye as he pleaded with looters not to burn down a store next to his house. He was a maintenance worker for L.A. County Parks and Recreation Department.

    Meeker Mardah Gibson? Did you ever hear his name?

    Gibson, a 35-year-old African-American, may have been talking on a gas-station pay phone when he took a shotgun blast to the chest. His body was found May 1. His wife, Valerie, survived him.

    William Anthony Ross?

    Ross, a 25-year-old African-American, burned to death inside a grocery store looted and torched in Koreatown. Ross died, curled up under a metal desk in the office, with a wad of cash in a pant pocket. The coroner ruled the death a homicide.

    Howard A. Epstein?

    Epstein, a 45-year-old white man from Orinda, was westbound on Slauson Avenue in South-Central, when someone in another car fired at his vehicle. The shot hit Epstein in the left temple. His Ford Thunderbird kept going until it hit a tree. While Epstein lay bleeding, rioters robbed him and looted his car. The crowd's hostility was so intense, police towed the car with the body still inside. Epstein had come to L.A. to check on his business. He left behind a wife, Stephanie.

    Thanh Lam? Does that name ring a bell?

    The riot did not keep Monterey Park resident Lam, a 25-year-old Vietnamese-American, from trying to make deliveries for his family's small grocery. He was eastbound on Alondra Boulevard, in his 1989 Toyota truck with a camper shell, and stopped at a red light at Willowbrook. A late-1970s or early-1980s blue Cadillac pulled up, and a front-seat passenger, described as an African-American man in his early 20s, yelled a racial slur and opened fire, hitting Lam four times, three times in the chest and once in the back.

    More than 50 people died in Watts during rioting about a beat-down on Rodney King, a felon with multiple convictions who feared that his parole would be revoked if he was convicted for DUI, and accordingly fled the police through the streets of Los Angeles at over 100 miles per hour.

    Parent

    I haven't watched "Cops." However, (none / 0) (#10)
    by oculus on Sat Dec 27, 2008 at 06:41:18 PM EST
    I do know there are circumstances in which law enforcement officers use force based on the circumstances confronting the officer(s).  Whether such use of force is justifiable is assessed by an objective standard based on the circumstances at the time.  Was teh officer in reasonable fear for his/her own safety or the safety of others?

    Parent