The Bad And Better Joe Klein
My defenses (kidding) of Joe Klein finally struck gold. He didn't genuflect (a la Mark "Freak Show" Halperin) at the altar of Hugh Hewitt. But Joe can't help but falsely smear Left Blogs saying:
JK: You know, the most recent thing that I did that got them [the Left Blogs] ticked off was in my column not this week, but last week. I reported that there was good news in Al Anbar Province . . . I did this based on a lot of reporting, and including a high-ranking military official in Iraq, and I was accused of taking dictation from the Bush administration by some of the left wing bloggers. . . . [I]t’s because there are, you know, this doesn’t represent everybody on the left. It only represents a small segment. But there are people who just don’t want good news from Iraq. . . . JK: They want us to lose
Come on Joe. Criticizing you is not wanting us to lose. I disagreed with the criticism actually but for crissakes, what is it about your ego that would equate criticism of you with wanting us to lose? Sound like Bush on that one.
But now for the somewhat better Klein:
HH: Joe, I want to know if you’ve read America Alone.JK: No, I haven’t read America Alone. What’s that?
HH: It’s Mark Steyn’s bestseller, New York Times.
JK: (laughing) Oh, it’s right wing propaganda. I read stuff in the middle, I talk to our generals, I talk to our intelligence community, I try and get, I don’t believe in much of the crap that’s coming from the left or right on this stuff. We’re not in World War IV, but we’re in a very serious situation, and we’re not…and up until Gates was hired, we haven’t, this administration hasn’t taken a very serious situation very seriously.
HH: I’m going back to your column, though. Do you read Victor Davis Hanson, last guy I’ll ask you about.
JK: Yes, from time to time. I think he’s ridiculous. He’s a wonderful historian, and his sense of what’s going on in Iraq right now is as foolish as Bernard Lewis’ sense.
HH: So Bernard Lewis, Victor Davis Hanson and Mark Steyn are all foolish?
JK: Yes, absolutely.
Now I say the better Joe Klein not because he knows what he is talking about. On Iraq, he really does not imo. And his reflexive Broderism is pretty appalling. But it is "better Joe" because he at least stands up to Hewitt and calls wingnuts wingnuts. And that is "better" than most of them.
| < The Harmful "Emptiness" of Political Reporting | News Conference: JFK Alleged Terror Plot Busted > |





