Mueller: From Now On, We'll Obey the Law
FBI Director Robert Mueller's testimony before the Senate Judiciary Committee amounts to this: Yes, we abused our Patriot Act authority by spying on Americans who weren't suspected of terrorism, even though we promised that we wouldn't, but now that we've been caught, we really really promise not to abuse that authority again, so please don't take it away.
Senator Leahy's response:
"Last year the administration sought new powers in the Patriot Act to appoint U.S. Attorneys without Senate confirmation and to more freely use National Security Letters," Leahy said in opening remarks. "The administration got these powers, and they have badly bungled both."
Last week, Leahy said "we need to consider whether Congress went too far" when it removed restrictions on FBI use of national security letters. The Senate should remove that authority altogether. If the FBI wants to snoop into personal information, it should get a warrant.
Senator Specter's proposed solution is to give the government even more power than it already has by "establishing a separate domestic intelligence agency like Britain's MI-5." We don't need an arm of government with no job to do beyond spying on Americans. Rather, we need a set of laws that reinforce the Framers' intent: if the executive branch wants to snoop, it should satisfy the judicial branch that it has probable cause to do so. If it can't make that minimal showing, it shouldn't be allowed to invade our privacy.
| < Tuesday Open Thread | The "Pragmatic" Iraq Supplemental Plan: GOP Senators Will "Win" It for Dems > |





