home

My Conversation With Mark Corallo Re: Leopold on Rove

Karl Rove's spokesman, Mark Corallo, called me at 8:20 a.m. Mountain Time today. He said someone had read him my post over the phone about my conversation with Jason Leopold (and he had picked up my voice-mail from Saturday night) and he wanted to respond. Here is Mr. Corallo's version:

1. He has never spoken with someone identifying himself as "Jason Leopold." He did have conversations Saturday and Sunday along the lines I described, but the caller identified himself as Joel something or other from the Londay Sunday Times. The calls were to his home number. At one point during their last conversation, he offered to call Joel back, and was given a cell phone number that began with 917. When he called the number back, it turned out not to be be a number for Joel.

2. Josh Gerstein and Byron York called him, not the other way around.

3. There was no meeting or communication between Luskin and Fitzgerald on Friday. Bob was not in the office on Friday at all. He was home, taking care of a sick cat.

4. Karl Rove did not tell the President he would resign.

5. Karl Rove has not been indicted nor told he would be indicted. As far as Corallo knows (and he is in contact with Luskin) Fitzgerald has not yet made up his mind as to whether to charge Rove. There are no charges.

6. He says there is not an ounce of truth to anything Jason wrote. He says he made it up. He also denies that Jason left him a message before the article ran.

7. He has received calls from the major papers on this and denied the story to all of them.

Mr. Corallo's tone was not angry. He was friendly and seemed sincere. If anything, he sounded somewhat bewildered and incredulous at how Jason could have written his article.

So, there you have it. A full and complete official Camp Rove denial of everything in Jason's article.

Now we wait and see. Jason has said if the story is false, he will publicly disclose his sources.

Mr. Corallo gave me his cell phone number for future questions. I asked him how late I could call him and he said up to 11 pm was fine for routine matters and any time if it was breaking news.

Update 4:30 pm: More from Mark Carallo:

The reason we were so "hot to dismiss a relatively unknown reporter writing for an online lefty journal," is because he caused real journalists to waste their time all weekend calling me (and in turn wasting my time) - that's right, every major network and newspaper called me and/or Bob Luskin starting on Friday morning and not ending until late last night;

....I got a call today from the real Joel Loria of the Sunday Times. ... you could call him and he will tell you that he had dinner with our Mr. Leopold last week.

< Leopold Responds to Corallo's Denial of Fitzgerald - Luskin Meeting | ABC News: Gov't Montioring Reporters' Phone Calls >
  • Premium Ads

  • Blog Ads

  • Contribute To TalkLeft

    donate to TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    Man, this is getting weird.

    Re: My Conversation With Mark Corallo Re: Leopold (none / 0) (#2)
    by scribe on Mon May 15, 2006 at 08:09:54 AM EST
    1, 2, 6. Someone's not speaking truthfully. We've got pretty well diametrically-opposed stories here. 3. A partner in a big international law firm with his docket holding one of the biggest cases going skipped work to care for a sick cat? OoooooKaaaaaay? Did he ever claim the dog eat his pleadings, too? I mean, given his probable billing rate, one could buy all the cats in the pound for one days' billings. 4,5. We'll see who's right. 7. So?

    Re: My Conversation With Mark Corallo Re: Leopold (none / 0) (#3)
    by scribe on Mon May 15, 2006 at 08:10:44 AM EST
    Oh, it was nice of Corallo to handle this professionally, regardless of the truth of the matters discussed.

    Wow, now you need to call Gerstein & Byron York to get their assertions-- plus hunt up a Joel at the London Times. This is getting deep and nasty! I am grateful for your efforts to shine light in this murky cesspool!

    Good idea too, getting the "latest hour I can call" time seeing how that so discombobulated Mr. Luskin, who was still exhausted and recovering I suppose, from his tender care of his kitty.

    Re: My Conversation With Mark Corallo Re: Leopold (none / 0) (#6)
    by orionATL on Mon May 15, 2006 at 08:18:00 AM EST
    such delicious detail. thanks tl

    One weird thing that jumped out immediately: if Leopold really did misidentify himself as "Joel of the London Sunday Times," as Corallo is clearly insinuating, why the hell would Corallo blast him for writing a defamatory article? Or does Corallo claim that that part of the conversation (which is based on Jason Leopold's accounting to you) never happened? On another topic, it seems like there must be some way to verify the simple fact of whether Fitzgerald was in Chicago or Washington last Friday, but IANAJ (I am not a journalist!) so I can't think of what it would be in light of Fitz's office refusing to comment on anything ...

    Someone is trying to get us all to have Rove fatigue. I got excited Saturday and chacked all day Sunday for confirmation. I'm sick and tired but mostly sick and tired of the crooks in this administration. I will celebrate every time a lie gets outed, a thug indicted, and will GOTV in 2006.

    Oh yeah
    I am grateful for your efforts to shine light in this murky cesspool!
    I just wanted to echo this a thousand fold. Weird stuff, and we Plameaholics (Fitzaholics?) are grateful for your efforts on this ... I suppose, and I don't know whether you feel like doing this at this point, that the next logical step would be to email Jason Leopold again and ask him whether he identified himself as Jason Leopold when he talked to Corallo. If he says yes, at that point we'll know that one of them is telling a pretty direct, balls to the wall lie (and, skeptical though I have been on this whole story, my money would be on the guy that works for Rove).

    I don't know who to believe, but both gentleman can consider themselves off of my holiday card list.

    sdf(Stu) the next logical step would be to email Jason Leopold again and ask him whether he identified himself as Jason Leopold when he talked to Corallo. Of course if we were the NSA, we'd have all this information already!

    Re: My Conversation With Mark Corallo Re: Leopold (none / 0) (#12)
    by squeaky on Mon May 15, 2006 at 08:32:33 AM EST
    Translation: Rove still has until early tomorrow morning to give up Cheney and possibly others or he is looking at jail time. Spinorama.

    Any significance in the number starting 917?
    holding one of the biggest cases going skipped work to care for a sick cat? OoooooKaaaaaay? Did he ever claim the dog eat his pleadings, too?
    No it couldn't manage another bite after eating my homework.

    Re: My Conversation With Mark Corallo Re: Leopold (none / 0) (#14)
    by scribe on Mon May 15, 2006 at 08:56:08 AM EST
    917 is an "overlay" area code, primarily for cell phones, in Manhattan, NYC.

    Regular Eschaton commentor Pseudonymous in NC was just saying that Jason Leopold was being interviewed on the radio this morning (he said it was on the Denver-Boulder 760AM station) saying that it's insane that people would give the Rove spokesperson more credence than him. Just to add to the pot.

    Very cool. Many thanks, TalkLeft--and your venture into reportage has turned out very well. Nice to have the denial so thorough and so much on the record.

    Resolving the conflicting stories over who called whom should be easy ... ... just ask the NSA.

    All of this is really a fascinating mini-drama. And I can't help but wonder why Team Rove is so hot to dismiss a relatively unknown reporter writing for an online lefty journal. It seems like an awful lot of "handling" for a relatively obscure-to-the-mainstream news report. Have blogs and online but not mainstream media finally garnered respect?

    Leopold said on Denver's 760AM station that Fitzgerald will make the announcement on Wednesday. This will prove whether or not Leopold's article was accurate. Leopold is standing by his story 100% and that he has been talking to his sources all weekend. We shall see how all this plays out.

    Well, since there are presumably still some companies selling phone records on the web, and since the FBI has purchased phone records, maybe someone will engage in "turnaround is fair play" and buy Mr. Corallo's phone records next month to see who called who this past week. Yes, I know it's stooping to their level, and I wouldn't do it, but there would be some poetic justice in it. -- "We have met the enemy and he is us." PogoWasRight.org

    Re: My Conversation With Mark Corallo Re: Leopold (none / 0) (#21)
    by Sydnie on Mon May 15, 2006 at 09:51:46 AM EST
    Luskin has never been shy about making comments before, why is he shying away from answering your questions now? You would think he would be the first to confirm that this is not factual, if that were the case. He wouldn't need to refer you, or anyone else, to a paid mouth PR guy. Fitz has asked for no gag order to be in effect so Luslin could speak to the article without fear. Rove was asked a question about his statements to McClean today at his speech at AEI. He referred the reporter back to the statement that Luskin made on April 26th, not to his PR guy at all. Statements from that far back vindicate Rove from the cloud of charges ... but .... haven't things possibly changed since that public statement from Luskin? Referral back to a previous position does nothing but delay the process of the reporter and buy time for Luskin to figure out how he is going to move the next piece on the board. I find it odd that Luskin is not blustering that his client is not in the type of jeopardy that he appears to be by Leopold's account. I have never known a high profile lawyer with "the truth" on their side to allow a "kitty" to capture his tongue.

    Re: My Conversation With Mark Corallo Re: Leopold (none / 0) (#22)
    by Tom Maguire on Mon May 15, 2006 at 09:56:55 AM EST
    Now we wait and see. Jason has said if the story is false, he will publicly disclose his sources. In other words, if he has been lying/misinformed about everything else, he will tell us something believable about this. Excellent. Up above was this question: One weird thing that jumped out immediately: if Leopold really did misidentify himself as "Joel of the London Sunday Times," as Corallo is clearly insinuating, why the hell would Corallo blast him for writing a defamatory article? The answer is probably in the pronouns used in Jeralyn's post: Jason said Corallo answered his call (and was wide awake) and told him his article was false, that it bordered on defamation, that Fitzgerald was not in Washington on Friday and that Luskin was not in his office on Friday. The word "his" may simply have come from Jason; Corallo may have been telling what he belived to be a third party Brit reporter that the Leopold report was false, defamatory, etc. Stray hint - since Brit laws on defamation are much tighter than here in the US (I don't know what a US reporter could say about Rove that *would* be defamatory), it does provide a nudge in the direction that Corallo thought he was talking to a Brit paper.

    I said this on another thread, but it's worth repeating. Carallo is not an attorney, he's a media manipulator, he can lie free of any legal encumbrance.

    Re: My Conversation With Mark Corallo Re: Leopold (none / 0) (#24)
    by jimakaPPJ on Mon May 15, 2006 at 10:04:30 AM EST
    Tom M quotes:
    Jason said Corallo answered his call (and was wide awake)
    And how does Jason know this? The same way he knew the indictment was done and Rove would surrender today and not speak???

    JimakaPPJ Jason said Corallo answered his call (and was wide awake) And how does Jason know this? The same way he knew the indictment was done and Rove would surrender today and not speak??? You obviously either didn't read Jeralyn's post on her call on Saturday night to Luskin, when he was so upset with her calling past his kitty's bedtime (yes I inferred the kitty and the bedtime, so don't get all excited!) or you are so lacking in a sense of humor or poetic symmetry that you couldn't grasp wry turn of the "wide awake" phrase.

    Re: My Conversation With Mark Corallo Re: Leopold (none / 0) (#26)
    by Tom Maguire on Mon May 15, 2006 at 10:15:38 AM EST
    I said this on another thread, but it's worth repeating. Carallo is not an attorney, he's a media manipulator, he can lie free of any legal encumbrance. Is Jason Leopold an attorney? Are there any encumbrances other than legal consequences that might steer someone towards telling the truth? Is there any benefit to Corallo from peddling an absurdly over-detailed lie, rather than just saying "No comment"? Is there any benefit to Leopold to making stuff up? My impression is that he gets paid for articles, and his history for scrupulous accuracy does not inspire confidence. Or, if Leopold's history is irrelevant, then why shouldn't Rove's history be irrelevant? Maybe we can just judge this on the merits with no reference to the history on either side.

    Corallo may not be lying if he has not been told. Since when are press people in the inner circle, especially when they need to divert from the truth. As for Leopold - yes, he has a history that includes plagiarism and loose reporting. His motives here - he did not need to make up a story that could ruin his career for good. He's been on target lately and I believe that he believes his sources. That he may have been set up is another story.....

    Rove indictment rumours on the blogs were discussed this afternoon on NPR's Day Today by Noah Adams...for all it was worth. NPR fluffy "news" magazine coopting blog bounce, and no real new insights by Noah "cheddar omlette" Adams, formerly a decent reporter. or from this post....

    Is Jason Leopold an attorney? Are there any encumbrances other than legal consequences that might steer someone towards telling the truth? Is there any benefit to Corallo from peddling an absurdly over-detailed lie, rather than just saying "No comment"? My comment was directed to the person who asked why Luskin would direct calls regarding Rove's status to Carallo. I do believe that as an attorney Luskin can't just outright lie. He can spin and parse, but I don't think he can lie. Maybe the attorneys here can clarify this if I'm mistaken. I also conjectured that perhaps Carallo is out to squash Leopold because he is too close. It's to Carallo's benefit to trash the veracity of a reporter who really might have the inside track and to do so before the case goes public like Libby's. Now, all that being said, does not mean I fall down on Leopold's side at this moment. Time will tell if his tale is true or not.

    Re: My Conversation With Mark Corallo Re: Leopold (none / 0) (#30)
    by Sailor on Mon May 15, 2006 at 12:46:01 PM EST
    As for Leopold - yes, he has a history that includes plagiarism and loose reporting
    When you slander a person shouldn't you provide links? (please, please ask me for links that disprove the swiftboating of Leopold.)

    Re: My Conversation With Mark Corallo Re: Leopold (none / 0) (#31)
    by jimakaPPJ on Mon May 15, 2006 at 01:41:23 PM EST
    scribe writes:
    . A partner in a big international law firm with his docket holding one of the biggest cases going skipped work to care for a sick cat?
    I have came home to take care of sick pets. And if Fitzgerald wasn't where Jason said he was, why would Luskin feel constrained to not take care of personal business? Sailor - I know nothing of Leopold, who does he report for? My advice to him would be, release your sources, right now. He's looking very bad. SharonW writes:
    All of this is really a fascinating mini-drama. And I can't help but wonder why Team Rove is so hot to dismiss a relatively unknown reporter writing for an online lefty journal.
    Maybe because it is wrong? Speechless - Well, you quoted Jason as saying something. Now you call it humor. Somehow I don't think Jason would find it funny.

    Re: My Conversation With Mark Corallo Re: Leopold (none / 0) (#32)
    by Che's Lounge on Mon May 15, 2006 at 01:54:51 PM EST
    My advice to him would be, release your sources, right now. He's looking very bad. Expose your sources now? Oh yeah, it's Jim. If Jason is right, Luskin and Carollo will suffer very little, reputation wise. If Jason is wrong, the left Blogosphere will suffer a la Rathergate. Even though 99% of the population is totally unaware of what is happening, this is a big deal on the internet. But I'm sure the next person to die on "Lost" is more important. Lost is right. Keep up the great work JM.

    One motive for a Rove spokesman's denial today is to keep the lid on until Bush's speech tonight is over and he gets whatever benefit he expects from it.

    I have concerns, especially since I've relied heavily on Leopold's writing for my many political posts, and I will be expecting some explanation before I'm ready to fully trust Leopold again. But one thing that occurs to me: Rove has mastered the art of disinformation and part of this looks like some intentional disinformation flak. It's hard not to notice that the game of feeding false information to the media and then reacting to that information was exactly how Plamegate went down -- with a few miscalculations by Libby and Rove. I haven't let Leopold off the hook yet, but much of his information does match other reporter's stories. Moreover, the news that Rove had been indicted was echoed by Joseph Wilson via Larry Johnson, and was predicted by Chris Matthews on Imus's show, so it's not as if Leopold is completely alone. And it is hard to believe that Rove's fifth grand jury appearence wasn't because of the threat of prosecution. I expect indictment soon, I also believe the Fitzgerald is waiting -- possibly because he wants to continue to play Libby off Rove -- and is in no rush to indict for very good reasons.

    jamen (none / 0) (#35)
    by dacontemil on Tue Oct 31, 2006 at 05:30:17 AM EST
    amateur6
    mateur27
    anal4
    anime6
    asian8
    ass9
    babe4
    bbw5
    bdsm6
    beach7
    bisexual8
    bizarre4
    black44
    blonde6
    blowjob7
    bondage2
    booty3
    bukkake9
    cartoon4
    exotic5
    celebrite5
    clitoris5
    closeup7
    cock4
    couple8
    creampie3
    cumshot6
    deepthroat7
    dildo9
    doublepenetration2
    drunk6
    ebony3
    ethnic2
    face9
    facial1
    fat4
    femdom55
    fetish7
    ffm8
    fingering2
    fisttime
    fisting8
    flashing3
    footjob2
    fucking7
    banggang3
    gay8
    gay69
    gloryhole1
    granny0
    hairy9
    handjob4
    hardcore6
    hentai8
    housewife4
    indian3
    interracial9
    japanese2
    latex6
    latina7
    lesbian8
    lingerie5
    maid8
    mardigras2
    masturbation7
    mature8
    maturee
    midget3
    milf6
    mmf5
    model5
    nude33
    nudist6
    oral9
    orgy3
    outdoor5
    pantie4
    pissing7
    plumper8
    pornstar3
    pregnant2
    puffy9
    pussy4
    redhead6
    rimjob7
    schoolgirl8
    shaving3
    shemale6
    showerbath3
    smoking2
    softcore2
    spanking1
    squirting5
    stories7
    strapon9
    swinger5
    teen6
    thong3
    threesome2
    tits2
    toes1
    toon55
    toy6
    tranny9
    ugly3
    virgin7
    voyeur3
    webcam22
    weird1
    wetshirt8
    cartes6
    cartesh
    cartesb
    cartes8
    carte7
    carte24
    carte33
    jeux33
    jeux24
    jeux34
    jeu263
    jeuuuu
    jeu33
    humour6
    recette8
    recettefree
    voitureee
    enfant9
    vacancesss
    familiale5
    truc6
    diaporamas5
    diaporamas2
    astuce6
    voyage3
    diaporama7
    diaporama2
    partitions2
    partition7
    fondsdecran9
    fonddecran6
    horoscopes2
    spectacle7
    massage5
    horoscope4
    tele2
    soluce8
    auto3
    tv9
    footbal4
    golf8
    erotiques8
    videocomique9
    histoire9
    couple3
    erotique7
    sport5
    videoscomiques8
    tunning2
    tatouages2
    tatouage5
    tarot8
    icone8
    lingerie2
    bebe7
    television6
    programme2
    codejeu9
    solutionjeu8
    ecransdeveille2
    f1rallye1
    ecrandeveille
    famille9
    touristique5
    tennis32
    ppsppt2
    cinema6
    yoga8
    wallpaper2
    cheat7
    tourisme2
    sportive66
    blagues5
    blague7
    imagehumour8
    voyager4
    illusion9
    safari2
    vacances4
    vacancesplus
    filmgratuit
    porngratuit
    xxxgratuit8
    pornogratuit8
    sexgratuit8
    sexegratuit7
    sexegratuit2
    moviegratuit3
    xgratuit6
    telechargementfilm7
    telechargementmovie8
    telechargementporn
    telechargementporno
    telechargementsex
    telechargementsexe
    telechargementx
    telechargermovie
    telechargerfilm
    telechargerporn
    telechargerporno
    telechargersex
    telechargersexe7
    telechargerx
    telechargerxxx
    sexe8
    sexe22
    sexeeee
    sex6
    sex23
    porno8
    porno9
    porno33
    aged8
    amazing9
    anime66
    asshole9
    babe7
    backseat3
    bang6
    bathing2
    beach6
    beauty7
    beaver5
    bed5
    tit8
    bimbo2
    bizarre6
    boy2
    busty1
    butt8
    cheerleader6
    chick8
    chinese6
    chubby2
    classy5
    clit2
    coed1
    corset1
    cum9
    cunt5
    curly7
    dick7
    dirty2
    doll4
    dorm3
    dress2
    drilled6
    drinking3
    feet8
    girlfriend2
    glasses7
    gorgeous3
    goth2
    granny8
    hidden9
    hirsute3
    hooter0
    horny2
    huge6
    jerking2
    jizz7
    juicy7
    kinky8
    kissing2
    leg1
    lick8
    lust2
    male1
    masturbating7
    melon8
    mom2
    naked6
    natural3
    nature9
    naughty3
    nipple7
    nympho8
    oiled3
    older2
    orgasm6
    oriental9
    outside3
    panty2
    penetrate1
    petite3
    pink1
    plump7
    pornstar8
    pretty2
    private5
    skinny8
    slut3
    smoke6
    spank7
    sperm9
    spread8
    stocking8
    strip7
    stripper8
    stud3
    student6
    sucking4
    sybian3
    tall3
    tease2
    topless4
    tranny6
    tub3
    twink3
    undressing4
    vagina6
    vibrator3
    vixen2
    whore1
    wives0

    recettes
    recettes2
    safari
    sexy
    sexy2
    soluce
    solutionjeu
    spectacle
    sport
    sportive
    tarot
    tatouage
    tatouages
    tele
    television
    tennis
    tourisme
    touristique
    truc
    tuning
    tv
    vacances2
    videocomique
    videoscomiques
    voiture
    voyage
    voyager
    wallpaper
    yoga

    erotique
    erotiques
    f1rallye
    familiale
    famille
    fonddecran
    fondsdecran
    football
    golf
    histoire
    horoscope
    horoscopes
    humour
    icone
    illusion
    imagehumour
    jeu
    jeu2
    jeu3
    jeux
    jeux2
    jeux3
    lingerie
    massage
    partition
    partitions
    ppsppt
    programme
    recette
    recette2

    astuce
    auto
    bebe
    blague
    blagues
    carte
    carte2
    carte3
    cartes
    cartes2
    cartes3
    cartes4
    cheat
    cinema
    codejeu
    couple
    diaporama
    diaporama2
    diaporamas
    diaporamas2
    ecrandeveille
    ecransdeveille
    enfant

    fetiche
    fetichisme
    film
    film2
    film3
    films
    films2
    films3
    girl
    gratuite
    gratuite2
    gratuite3
    gros
    grosse
    hardcore
    homosexuel
    hot
    image
    image2
    latinas
    lesbian
    mature
    mature2
    models
    movie
    mure
    nude
    nudiste
    orgasme
    orgie

    amatrice
    anus
    asian
    ass
    baise
    beurette
    bikini
    bisexuel
    black
    black2
    blonde
    boob
    brune
    celebrite
    chaleur
    charme
    clitoris
    cochon
    couille
    enculer
    erotique
    erotisme
    etudiante
    exhibitionniste
    fellation
    femme
    femme2
    femme3
    fesse

    pornographie
    pussy
    rasee
    rousse
    sado
    salope
    sex
    sex2
    sexe
    sexe2
    sexuelle
    sexy
    sodomie
    suce
    suceuse
    teen
    tit
    toon
    transsexuelle
    video
    video2
    video3
    videos
    videos2
    videos3
    voyeur
    webcam
    x
    x2
    xxx

    adulte
    amateur
    amateur2
    anal
    asiatique
    bite
    coquin
    cul
    gay
    gay2
    hard
    histoire
    jeune
    lesbienne
    manga
    noire
    nu
    penis
    photo
    photo2
    photo3
    pied
    pipe
    poitrine
    porn
    porno
    porno2