home

Another Airborne Virus

(Guest Posted by TalkLeft's Man in Hollywood)

Over a decade ago, Robert Hughes wrote "Culture of Complaint", an expansive diatribe about the "fraying of America" that directed cooly reasoned blasts at both the left and right hemispheres of the cultural landscape. Among them, Ronald Reagan ("Reagan educated the people down to his level. He left the country a little stupider in 1988 than it had been in 1980, and a lot more tolerant of lies") and the art world itself, for its subservience to special interest groups. Hughes argued that the rise of political correctness was flooding the galleries and diluting the art... culture itself was drowning in a sea of overweening "political etiquette".

Highly critical of those who shared his turf yet able to respect the mercurial nature of both flakey artists and humorless social activists, Hughes' 1993 book was a great tightrope act. It was, to use a phrase recently demonized by the right wing, nuanced.

Who would have thought that just three years later Roger Ailes would flip Hughes' polemic on its head and use it as a inspiration for Fox News?

The right wing subjugation of the media has been fueled by its appropriation of a "culture of complaint". It was (and is) everywhere... over the airwaves, internet message boards, even disguised as book reviews on Amazon.com. The rally cry hasn't changed in all those years: "We are the Underdog".

You can still see stuff like this on countless right wing blogs:

"... they (CNN) have made positive changes. They are still left leaning, but not as bad as they used to be... they have limited their liberal politics to Wolf Blitzer and his  propoganda (Sic) show "the Situation Room", for the most part. They were forced to change to try and get their market share back from Fox News, the home of #1 ratings and the highest news market share in America.

This guy has one thing right: CNN is indeed scratching and clawing to get their market share back, all the way to the bottom of the barrel.  Last week they hired Glenn Beck, the host of a nationally syndicated talk show broadcast over the Premiere Radio Networks and owned by Clear Channel.

What was it about Beck that attracted CNN? Well, he's familiar with the Fox playbook. He wrote a weighty paperback called "The Real America" where he agrees that "Political correctness is the classic Great Idea Gone Wrong".

As for Beck's broadcasting skills, here are some examples of what CNN is keen to share with their audience...

"(I'm) thinking about killing Michael Moore"

"Cindy Sheehan is a tragedy slut."

"[T]his is horrible to say, and I wonder if I'm alone in this -- you know, it took me about a year to start hating the 9-11 victims' families? Took me about a year."

Living in Hollywood, I've developed a nose for raw talent...  and I can tell right away that these tender homilies are what Ken Jautz, Vice President of CNN Worldwide News, had in mind when he characterized Beck as "cordial...  conversational, not confrontational."

Jautz also describes him as "the next piece in the puzzle." I'm glad they're finally getting serious about solving that old "reporting the news" puzzle.

The Culture of Complaint invites Al-Qaeda to level San Francisco and celebrates the shooting death of an innocent man ("five in the noggin is fine!"). Now CNN has shined up a new bully pulpit and Glenn Beck is settling in, ready to help spread the love.

Liberals have long been channeling Rip Van Winkle in their response to these rancorous blowhards... but signs of life could be seen in last week's Bunker Hill charge into the Washington Post blog.

Deborah Howell, the Post's ombudsman, repeated the White House spin that Jack Abramoff donated money to Democrats and furious readers stormed the comment section at the Post's website. Soon the joint was overflowing with all nature of protest... angry, barbed and intractable.

But not unremovable. Wouldn't you know it, the second liberals show some collective moxie, they get shut down. Jim Brady, the executive editor of washingtonpost.com, pulled those comments because they were "abusive" and "were very, very nasty, using words that I didn't even know existed..."

"Abusive"? "Nasty"? If those commentators were that bad, send 'em over to CNN... they might still be hiring. Remember, Glenn Beck is just a part of the puzzle.

< FBI Investigates CA's Use of Prisoners As 'Peacekeepers' | Russert and Obama: Race-Based Questions? >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    Re: Another Airborne Virus (none / 0) (#1)
    by Talkleft Visitor on Sun Jan 22, 2006 at 07:18:57 PM EST
    "We are all in the gutter, But some of us are looking at the stars"

    Re: Another Airborne Virus (none / 0) (#2)
    by Dadler on Sun Jan 22, 2006 at 07:45:03 PM EST
    I hope TL's man in Hollywood is doing better than TL's scuffling screenwriter, barely clinging to his WGA membership, his sanity, and any actual writing instincts he once had. And CNN is weak, has been for many years. When Wolf Blitzer is considered your house lefty, well, you gotta look a little to the right to see him. Anderson Cooper, while pleasant, has about as much passionate journalistic edge as a jar of mayonaise. I mean, seriously, can you even imagine a REAL muckraker on the msm airwaves today? I can more easily imagine a flock of pigeons attacking me with teapots.

    Re: Another Airborne Virus (none / 0) (#3)
    by squeaky on Sun Jan 22, 2006 at 08:10:07 PM EST
    nicely put!! I read the comments at WaPo, before they were deleted, and they were spot on. Any attempt to discredit them by calling them obsene personal attacks is purely defensive tack hoping to change the subject.

    Re: Another Airborne Virus (none / 0) (#4)
    by scarshapedstar on Sun Jan 22, 2006 at 09:34:11 PM EST
    they (CNN) have made positive changes. They are still left leaning, but not as bad as they used to be... they have limited their liberal politics to Wolf Blitzer
    HAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAH pant... wheeze... stop, you're killing me.

    Re: Another Airborne Virus (none / 0) (#5)
    by jimcee on Sun Jan 22, 2006 at 09:46:18 PM EST
    Robert Hughes is a rather nuanced writer and his Culture Of Complaint still reasonates today. The quote you used by him can be taken in many contextual ways. Yours, in which the RR message made Americans stupider with his presence or another way in that the RR message was very simple, truthful and effective. You can choose whichever you want. As you said, 'nuanced'. Hughes has been able to appeal to both sides of the aisle because his prose is not as much polemic as it is argumentative in the classical liberal way. It is the mark of a good writer/thinker/critic to allow the reader to decide on which side his argument lies. In a way very similar to Chistopher Hitchens' work. If you enjoy his writing style and have any interest in the founding of Australia or human nature in general I would suggest his book The Fatal Shore. As far as CNN going 'Right' it is a natural progression because if they had gone any further Left they would have become Pravda. If somebody on the Right thinks that Blitzer is a Lefty probably has never watched his show. He is about as center as any news service gets. Beck on the other hand is just childish but CNN must think that he'll garner the young demographic that advertisers look for and in the end CNN is in the business of making money. As far as the WaPo deleting comments that is just wrong unless they were abusive but I'll hold my opinion having not seen the thread. As far as comparing it to the charge at the Battle of Bunker (Breed's) Hill, you might want to read up on who did the charging there and who took the most casualities.

    Re: Another Airborne Virus (none / 0) (#6)
    by Talkleft Visitor on Sun Jan 22, 2006 at 10:01:04 PM EST
    I really don't yell any more because we are running right into a third world war and people just don't see it.

    Re: Another Airborne Virus (none / 0) (#7)
    by Talkleft Visitor on Mon Jan 23, 2006 at 08:00:29 AM EST
    Fred... we are running right into a third world war and people just don't see it. You are one of them.... open your eyes... we have been fighting WWIII for several years now!