home

Judge Kozinski Announces Retirement

9th Circuit appeals court judge Alex Kozinski is resigning immediately due to 15 allegations of sexual harassment.

In a statement provided by his lawyer, Kozinski apologized, saying that he “had a broad sense of humor and a candid way of speaking to both male and female law clerks alike” and that, “in doing so, I may not have been mindful enough of the special challenges and pressures that women face in the workplace.”

"It grieves me to learn that I caused any of my clerks to feel uncomfortable; this was never my intent,” he said. “For this I sincerely apologize."

His full statement is here.

< FCC Repeals Net Neutrality Rules | Suburban vs. Rural and Faith-Based Republicans >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    I can't help but think (5.00 / 1) (#1)
    by CST on Mon Dec 18, 2017 at 12:51:59 PM EST
    When I see these kinds of announcements - How many?

    As in, how many women stopped working, resigned, left the field, quit, were fired, etc... because of this one person's @sshole behavior that is now in the news losing their job.

    Thinking of people like Lauren Green and Mira Sorvino right now.

    The part that got to me was the classically (5.00 / 1) (#3)
    by Peter G on Mon Dec 18, 2017 at 01:44:46 PM EST
    subjunctive "in doing so, I may not have been mindful enough of ...." Why in the world could he not, at this point, have had the decency to say "I now realize, many years after I should have, that in doing so I was painfully and inexcusably oblivious to ...."

    There's something setting my teeth on (none / 0) (#2)
    by Anne on Mon Dec 18, 2017 at 01:30:20 PM EST
    edge about
    "I may not have been mindful enough of the special challenges and pressures that women face in the workplace."

    I might have felt better about it he had gone on to say: "because they have to work with a-holes like me."

    And does he think that just because complaints werem't lodged by men - assuming that's the case - that the men who worked for him were not just okay with how the women were being treated, but were okay with his "broad sense of humor and candid way of talking?"

    I wonder: what would his reaction have been had his clerks - male and female - given as good as they got, if they had adopted his same sense of humor and candid way of talking?  I'm thinking he may have felt they were being insubordinate.

    The appropriateness of someone's behavior should not hinge on the gender of the person or persons at whom it is directed.  People are entitled to respect, period.  But it seems there's still an attitude of having earned the right to act however one wants on the basis of seniority or power (and after you pay your dues in the trenches, you, too, can treat people like crap and not give a damn who you offend).

    I don't know - that "special challenges" thing has a feel of "sigh...I wish women would make up their minds."

    I did read a statement by a male clerk (none / 0) (#8)
    by Towanda on Mon Dec 18, 2017 at 06:11:37 PM EST
    saying that he had not realized the reason why a woman clerk changed so much throughout their experience. It was terribly sad. That male clerk had more compassion than does this bozo judge who tormented her.

    Parent
    I don't understand how this stuff transpires. (none / 0) (#4)
    by Chuck0 on Mon Dec 18, 2017 at 01:53:36 PM EST
    I've been in the workplace for 41 years. Starting at 17 in the US Navy. I have been a supervisor and a people manager. I have had female bosses and worked in departments where nearly all of my co-workers were female.

    I do not understand these sexual situations transpire or come about. I know it happens. I have winced in the past when a younger male co-worker at my current job, once mentioned the "eye-candy" in the department. I never considered work the place for flirtation.

    I will confess that in those 41 years, I have rarely, if ever, socialized with co-workers. It's just never been the place I look for friendships or relationships. I go to work to earn money. I am professional with everyone. I don't flirt, don't make sexual innuendos, don't  tell inappropriate jokes. It's not hard. It's actually really, really easy.

    I guess it's a certain personality trait that looks at the workplace as a site for sexual conquest.


    Exactly, your last sentence (5.00 / 1) (#6)
    by Towanda on Mon Dec 18, 2017 at 05:23:23 PM EST
    gets it. It's not about friendship. It's not really about sex.

    It's about power.

    Parent

    Another aspect of this situation (none / 0) (#5)
    by Peter G on Mon Dec 18, 2017 at 04:15:38 PM EST
    that is bothering me is that Judge Kozinski has for many years functioned as a "feeder judge" to Supreme Court clerkships -- the most prestigious of all jobs for recent law school graduates. That is, many of his clerks (legal research and editorial assistants) went on to clerk at the Supreme Court for Justice O'Connor, or Justice Kennedy, or Justice Breyer, inter alia, on his recommendation, and the Justices looked to him for such recommendations. Did these clerks never confide in the Justices (O'Connor in particular), with whom law clerks have a highly confidential and privileged (in both senses), if not in many instances intimate (in no improper sense) relationship, about their experience with Kozinski? Any of the Justices could have spoken with him about the effect his conduct was having on some of the legal elite -- the women in particular -- who worked or might have worked with him, and could have warned him that some day this behavior was going to come home to roost and in all likelihood end his career.

    An interesting (none / 0) (#7)
    by KeysDan on Mon Dec 18, 2017 at 06:02:33 PM EST
    remembrance by Slate writer, Dahlia Lithwick, encapsulated by "since every one knew about it...it must be OK.  It never was."  Kozinski's retirement was immediate; hopefully, he will not look toward, or be granted, senior status (part time).  He can, at age 67 and 32  years service, retire at full salary.

    In federal court terminology (none / 0) (#9)
    by Peter G on Mon Dec 18, 2017 at 07:15:16 PM EST
    retiring is not the same as assuming senior status. Kozinski has announced his retirement. As a result, he is no longer a judge at all, although by tradition he can continue to use the honorific title for himself (although he very well may not), and might anticipate others' addressing him by that title.

    Parent
    20180720 (none / 0) (#10)
    by xiaojun on Thu Jul 19, 2018 at 09:27:49 PM EST
    20180720 junda
    jimmy choo sunglasses
    trailblazers jerseys
    cheap jordans
    christian louboutin outlet
    michael kors outlet online
    ugg boots
    coach outlet
    nike store
    malone souliers mules
    canada goose coats
    north face jackets
    harry winston jewelry
    nike factory outlet
    pandora charms
    air more uptempo
    canada goose outlet
    cavaliers jerseys
    polo ralph lauren
    polo ralph lauren
    oakley sunglasses
    diesel jeans
    michael kors outlet
    air jordan release dates
    christian louboutin shoes
    kate spade outlet
    uggs outlet
    air max 97
    stuart weitzman shoes
    reebok outlet store
    coach outlet
    ray ban sunglasses
    michael kors outlet
    coach outlet
    coach outlet store online
    true religion jeans
    cheap jordans
    ferragamo outlet
    air max 90
    uggs outlet
    giuseppe zanotti outlet
    mbt shoes
    longchamp outlet
    calvin klein jeans
    canada goose jackets
    jordan shoes
    longchamp outlet
    ugg outlet
    michael kors outlet
    jordan shoes
    coach outlet
    pandora charms
    fitflops sale clearance
    ray ban sunglasses
    nike roshe one
    chloe sunglassess
    nike lunarglide
    jeep shoes
    nike shoes
    visvim shoes
    bulls jerseys
    canada goose jackets
    ferragamo outlet
    new balance shoes
    polo ralph lauren
    fitflops
    fitflops sale
    swarovski crystal
    alife clothing
    moncler outlet
    canada goose outlet
    cheap jordans
    mulberry handbags
    coach outlet online
    pandora outlet
    grizzlies jerseys
    adidas trainers
    uggs outlet
    bottega veneta outlet
    birkenstock sandals
    balenciaga sneakers
    jordan 32
    canada goose jackets
    fitflops sale clearance
    cheap jordans
    ray ban sunglasses
    christian louboutin outlet
    adidas outlet
    cheap mlb jerseys
    under armour outlet
    cheap jordans
    jordan shoes
    polo outlet
    fila shoes
    minnetonka outlet
    christian louboutin outlet
    michael kors outlet
    golden goose sneakers
    fossil watches
    coach outlet
    nike shoes
    air jordan shoes
    moncler outlet
    canada goose jackets
    uggs
    polo ralph lauren
    ray ban sunglasses
    kings jerseys
    michael kors wallets
    fitflops sale clearance
    ubiq shoes
    michael kors outlet
    nike pegasus
    air jordan retro
    true religion outlet
    arcteryx jacket
    michael kors outlet
    moncler outlet
    knicks jerseys
    ugg outlet
    true religion jeans
    ugg outlet
    clarks shoes
    ferragamo outlet
    michael kors handbags
    michael kors outlet
    ugg outlet
    pandora charms
    brequet wathes
    coach outlet
    canada goose parka
    cleveland cavaliers jersey
    canada goose outlet
    coach outlet online
    nike revolution
    longchamp outlet
    polo ralph lauren
    ferragamo shoes
    coach outlet online
    gentle monster sunglasses
    uggs outlet
    christian louboutin shoes
    kate spade outlet
    baltimore ravens jerseys
    mishka clothing
    ugg outlet
    dansko shoes
    ralph lauren polo shirts
    stephen curry shoes
    nike air max 2015
    moncler jackets
    michael kors outlet
    ugg outlet
    oakley sunglasses
    air max 97
    air max 90
    cazal sunglasses
    air jordan 12
    coach outlet online
    ferragamo outlet
    kate spade outlet
    kevin durant jerseys
    michael kors
    moncler jackets
    tods outlet
    kobe shoes
    air max 95
    coach outlet
    coach outlet
    dc shoes
    adidas crazy
    chrome hearts outlet
    pandora charms
    pandora charms sale clearance
    barbour jackets
    ugg boots
    canada goose outlet
    lakers jerseys
    michael kors outlet
    palladium boots
    kate spade outlet
    hawks jerseys
    ralph lauren polo
    coach factory outlet
    nba jerseys
    pandora jewelry
    barcelona jersey
    tory burch outlet
    celtics jerseys
    uggs outlet
    pandora charms
    oakley sunglasses
    michael kors outlet
    ralph lauren polo shirts
    longchamp solde
    uggs outlet
    warriors jerseys
    air max 90
    jordan shoes
    canada goose outlet
    cheap nhl jerseys
    suns jerseys
    true religion jeans
    nuggets jerseys
    michael kors
    nike outlet
    jerseys from china
    indianapolis colts jerseys
    denver broncos jerseys
    ralph lauren pas cher
    kate spade outlet
    ray ban sunglasses
    polo outlet
    ray ban sunglasses
    mac makeup
    pistons jerseys
    kappa clothing
    canada goose jackets
    stussy clothing
    tory burch outlet
    ecco shoes
    canada goose outlet
    longchamp handbags
    y3 shoes
    coach handbags
    michael kors
    saucony shoes
    michael kors outlet
    ugg outlet
    coach outlet
    hornets jerseys
    polo ralph lauren
    air max uk
    canada goose
    lakers jerseys
    true religion uk
    mcm outlet
    air force 1
    true religion outlet
    toms shoes
    pandora jewelry
    pandora outlet
    pandora charms
    harden shoes
    coach outlet online
    prada shoes
    cheap jordans
    nike air max
    cheap jordans
    ugg outlet
    burberry outlet
    swarovski outlet
    cartier jewelry
    canada goose outlet
    adidas outlet
    fingerlings monkey
    10 deep clothing
    celine outlet
    ralph lauren polo shirts
    birkenstock outlet
    ugg outlet
    nike revolution
    nfl jerseys wholesale
    true religion jeans
    michael kors outlet
    coach outlet
    columbia sportswear
    nba jerseys
    isabel marant shoes
    coach outlet
    ray ban sunglasses
    soccer shoes
    hermes birkin
    polo outlet
    michael kors uk
    asics shoes
    gucci outlet
    world cup jerseys
    polo ralph lauren
    reebok trainers
    givenchy jewelry
    mavericks jerseys
    toms shoes
    nhl jerseys
    five fingers shoes
    pandora charms
    christian louboutin outlet
    polo ralph lauren
    bally shoes
    michael kors outlet
    chicago blackhawks jerseys
    oakley sunglasses
    pandora charms
    football shirts
    gucci outlet
    nike roshe
    air jordan 3
    converse shoes
    ugg outlets
    longchamp solde
    fendi handbags
    swarovski outlet
    kd 10 elite
    nets jerseys
    spurs jerseys
    brequet wathes
    jimmy choo shoes
    louboutin shoes
    james harden jerseys
    fred perry polo shirts
    michael kors outlet
    jack wolfskin
    yeezy boost
    coach canada
    mulberry outlet
    nba jerseys
    hermes belt
    canada goose jackets
    canada goose jackets
    canada goose outlet
    pandora
    canada goose outlet
    air jordan 4
    coach outlet
    76ers jerseys
    clippers jerseys
    kate spade outlet
    ray ban sunglasses
    simulation shoes
    camel shoes
    nhl jerseys
    air max 90
    fitflops outlet
    kate spade outlet
    supra shoes
    ugg boots
    oakley sunglasses
    ray ban sunglasses
    manchester united jersey
    polo ralph lauren
    jordan shoes
    longchamp bags
    canada goose jackets
    coach outlet
    true religion jeans
    nike store
    balmain jeans
    houston texans jerseys
    pandora jewelry
    cheap jordans
    oakley sunglasses
    timberwolves jerseys
    christian louboutin outlet
    ugg outlet
    supreme uk
    jordan shoes
    coach outlet
    coach outlet
    mizuno running shoes
    longchamp pliage
    canada goose outlet
    tory burch outlet
    wellensteyn jackets
    michael kors
    karen millen dresses
    uggs outlet
    ugg boots
    tory burch outlet
    alexander mcqueen shoes
    ysl outlet
    michael kors handbags
    mulberry handbags
    yeezy boost 350
    ray ban sunglasses
    canada goose outlet
    nike air max 90
    ferragamo outlet
    polo ralph lauren
    huf clothing
    jazz jerseys
    canada goose outlet
    nike shoes
    uggs outlet
    true religion outlet
    ralph lauren outlet
    miu miu handbags
    lacoste soldes
    nike free
    marc jacobs outlet
    wizards jerseys
    polo outlet
    cheap jordans
    mulberry bags
    bcbg dresses
    ugg outlet
    tory burch outlet
    nike dunks
    coach outlet online
    isabel marant outlet
    soccer jerseys
    nike store uk
    adidas wings
    michael kors outlet
    coach outlet
    toms shoes
    salomon shoes
    true religion jeans
    michael kors outlet
    ugg boots clearance
    dolce and gabbana
    coach outlet
    michael kors outlet
    jordan shoes
    belstaff jackets
    michael kors outlet
    canada goose jackets
    lebron james shoes
    merrell shoes
    michael kors outlet
    off white
    dior outlet
    nike cortez
    basketball shoes
    ferragamo shoes
    coach outlet
    michael kors outlet
    burberry outlet
    cheap snapbacks
    mulberry handbags
    bulgari jewelry
    audemars piguet watches
    supreme clothing
    basketball jerseys
    coach outlet online
    cheap football shirts
    cheap jordans
    air max 1
    suicoke sandals
    oakley sunglasses
    bape clothing
    gucci outlet
    michael kors handbags
    ugg outlet
    mont blanc pens
    bvlgari jewelry
    heat jerseys
    g-star jeans
    keen shoes
    moncler outlet
    coach outlet
    chloe outlet
    pandora charms
    cheap jerseys
    michael kors outlet
    san francisco 49ers jerseys
    furla handbags
    true religion outlet
    true religion jeans
    montblanc pens
    light up shoes
    adidas uk
    canada goose outlet
    mulberry bags
    nfl jersey wholesale
    coach outlet
    magic jerseys
    fitflops sale
    raptors jerseys
    herve leger outlet
    armani exchange
    canada goose outlet
    ugg boots
    michael kors handbags
    canada goose outlet
    canada goose jackets
    coach outlet online
    ray ban sunglasses
    pandora charms
    polo ralph lauren
    polo ralph lauren
    pacers jerseys
    canada goose jackets
    nobis outlet
    ray ban sunglasses
    lacoste polo shirts
    air jordan shoes
    ugg boots
    air huarache
    air huarache
    swarovski crystal
    canada goose outlet
    nike tennis
    cheap jordans
    true religion jeans
    kd 9
    carrera sunglasses
    polo ralph lauren
    hermes outlet
    jordan shoes
    oakley sunglasses
    pelicans jerseys
    canada goose outlet
    michael kors outlet
    christian louboutin outlet
    links of london
    kevin durant shoes
    longchamp handbags
    michael kors outlet
    michael kors outlet
    cheap mlb jerseys
    cheap jordans
    vans shoes
    givenchy handbags
    champion clothing
    golden state warriors jerseys
    polo ralph lauren
    pandora charms
    a bathing ape
    true religion jeans
    air max 2017
    cheap nfl jerseys
    oakley sunglasses
    cheap jordans
    kobe bryant shoes
    yeezy boost
    manolo blahnik outlet
    chopard jewelry
    chelsea jersey
    michael kors outlet
    mulberry handbags
    canada goose outlet
    san antonio spurs jerseys
    michael kors outlet
    longchamp pas cher
    michael kors outlet
    swarovski outlet
    coach factory outlet
    prada sunglasses
    prada handbags
    ugg outlet
    fitflops shoes
    ed hardy clothing
    adidas soccer shoes
    le coq sportif shoes
    kate spade outlet
    tory burch outlet
    air jordan 4
    coach outlet online
    michael kors outlet
    van cleef & arpels jewelry
    jordan shoes
    christian louboutin outlet
    puma outlet
    true religion jeans
    kevin durant shoes
    nike presto
    michael kors outlet
    burberry outlet
    real madrid jersey
    freshjive clothing
    adidas nmd
    coach outlet online
    fitflops
    adidas nmd
    ray ban sunglasses
    bucks jerseys
    tory burch outlet
    oakley sunglasses
    cheap jerseys
    canada goose outlet
    tag heuer watches
    longchamp handbags
    tory burch outlet
    denver broncos jerseys
    nike foamposite
    valentino outlet
    polo shirts
    guess factory
    thunder jerseys
    gucci handbags
    gucci outlet
    louboutin pas cher
    michael kors handbags
    canada goose outlet
    ugg outlet
    coach factory outlet
    canada goose jackets
    christian louboutin outlet
    michael kors
    nike blazer pas cher
    canada goose outlet
    rockets jerseys
    coach handbags
    nike air force 1
    prada outlet
    longchamp handbags
    hermes outlet
    oakley sunglasses
    coach outlet
    michael kors outlet
    polo outlet
    kate spade outlet
    kyrie 4
    mulberry outlet
    burberry outlet
    ray ban outlet
    soccer jerseys
    kate spade outlet
    kate spade outlet
    undefeated clothing
    dsquared2 jeans
    coach outlet
    nike outlet
    ugg boots clearance
    kobe 9
    chrome hearts outlet
    michael kors outlet online
    swarovski outlet
    oakley sunglasses
    true religion jeans
    canada goose jackets
    oakley sunglasses
    kate spade outlet
    balenciaga sneakers
    futbol baratas