home

Live Opening Statements in James Holmes Case

Arapahoe County District Attorney George Brauchler is giving the opening statement for the prosecution in the trial of James Holmes. It's being televised on Channel 7 in Denver (thankfully no commentary so far.) Above is the streaming version from Fox News, also no commentary so far.

Why is the elected District Attorney trying this case personally? My guess: This is his stepping stone to a run for Congress or Governor. He is a very fluid speaker, he's got a powerpoint going but he's not using notes. His speech is free of "ums" and "ahs," and his tone is modulated and conversational. I didn't see the beginning so I can't tell what his theme is. He doesn't use trilogies to continually bring it home. Instead, he's doing a chronological presentation. [More...]

He says Holmes is supersmart and was manipulating his psych tests. He talks about his delusions and says they aren't really delusions.

He says he claimed he would make himself feel better and increase his self-worth by killing. That's not a delusion, a delusion would be if you think if you don't act, California would fall into the ocean.

The jury will see his google chats and emails with his girlfriend.

He weaves the stories of the victims into his discussion of his emails with his girlfriend, with the screen alternating between showing the emails and photos of the victims.

He says Holmes is devastated when his girlfriend broke up with him. He still works out twice a week.

An hour later: Brauchler is still going. I still can't tell what his theme is, he doesn't seem to have a phrase for it.

Update: The New York Times details the defense opening which I didn't get to see. It was given by two of his lawyers, Dan King and Katherine Spengler. From news reports: King showed the jury a video of Holmes in jail (no link due to autoplaying video.):

Holmes was found naked, licking walls, eating lunch meat between two paper cups. He sucked his thumb and cried.

King told the jury: "Look at the video, and you tell me if he would do this for notoriety."

All 20 doctors who examined him said he suffers from mental illness -- schizophrenia. The question is