home

Ohio Report on Death Row Suicide: Prison Guard Logs Falsified

Ohio Death Row Inmate Billy Slagle committed suicide on in the early morning hours of August 4, three days before his scheduled execution. An official "after action review report" publicly released yesterday finds the guards did not make their required rounds every 30 minutes as required and that the electronic logs about one guard's rounds that evening were falsified. Videos show the actual time the rounds occurred.

According to the review, DRC officer John McCollister, 30, falsely indicated on the prison's electronic log that Slagle's death row cell was checked consistently in 30-minute intervals, as required by the DRC, during the overnight shift.

The log shows rounds were conducted in the required intervals beginning at 10 p.m. Aug. 3 – when the shift began -- until about 5 a.m. Aug. 4, when Slagle's body was found hanging in the cell. The DRC review states that corrections officer Clay Putnam, 19, conducted the shift's first check on Slagle's cell at 11:20 p.m. and that he completed rounds once every hour beginning just after 2 a.m.

The actual report is available here. It concludes: [More...]

It appears from the full investigation of the incident by CCI and DRC/OSC that Officer Putnam did not perform rounds as required by Post Orders. Additionally, it appears that Officer McCollister, and possibly Officer Putnam, did falsify the electronic log book for rounds.

No interviews were done of these employees by CCI after-action or DRC/OSC after action teams. Both employees are on administrative leave, and these facts were reported to the Ohio State Highway Patrol. CCI has been advised that the Ohio State Highway Patrol does not intend to bring criminal charges against Putnam and McCollister.

The report also says all six officers on death row units that night were relief officers without training specific to death row, and one of the officers was still on probationary status. On the training inadequacy:

Relevant Facts: On the night of the incident, 28 of the 39 security posts were filled with a relief officer. In the Death Row blocks that evening, all 6 officers