home

Jury to Begin Deliberations in Victor Bout Case

The prosecution and defense gave their closing arguments Monday in the trial of Russian businessman Viktor Bout, accused of agreeing with pretend FARC members to sell weapons to be used against the U.S. in Colombia. The elaborate DEA sting began in Curacao, continued in Denmark, Russia, Romania and Moscow, and culminated in Thailand. The heart of the defense argument:

Mr. Dayan’s core argument was that Mr. Bout had humored the supposed FARC representatives’ interest in weapons, and even encouraged it, in an attempt to sell two cargo planes that he intended to persuade the men were necessary for the delivery of the weapons. Mr. Dayan emphasized that Mr. Bout never actually believed the men were members of FARC and said his client was “acting out” throughout their dealings; a weapons deal, Mr. Dayan said, was never agreed upon, nor did Mr. Bout ever plan on delivering any military equipment.

Mr. Dayan said that by the time of his arrest, Mr. Bout had made the transition from a legal arms-dealing trade to other business opportunities, like real estate, and the defense lawyer seemed to blame the fiasco on Mr. Smulian, Mr. Bout’s former associate. While Mr. Bout fought extradition in Thai courts after his arrest, Mr. Smulian voluntarily traveled to the United States and has cooperated with prosecutors for three and a half years.

[ More...]

Mr. Dayan argued Andrew Smulian, Mr. Bout's former business colleague with whom he hadn't done business in ten years, was the architect of the plan who became "intoxicated" by power and the "thought of a retirement plan."

That much is borne out by the evidence. The DEA had an informant, Mike Snow, approach Smulian and got him to meet with the two major informants, Guatemalan Carlos Sagastume and Nicaraguan Ricardo Jardenero, who proposed the deal to Smulian in Curacao, hoping he would reel in Bout.

Smulian was arrested with Bout in Bangkok, but immediately agreed to cooperate with authorities. He was brought to New York, charged and pleaded guilty to all counts, hoping for a sentence concession. Considering he's 70 years old, he needs one.

There are two competing versions of Bout that have emerged during the trial. The Government's version is that Bout has always been an arms dealer and the fake Farc informants merely provided him with an opportunity he was all too eager t