home

Apple iPhone or Treo?

I've been reading all day about the Apple iPhone. It looks very cool. But I kept wondering, what does it have that the Treo doesn't have?

I just got the Treo 680 over the holidays, so the TL kid could take my Motorola Razor - he had a dinosaur of a Nokia.

Aside from the fact that the Treo's phone reception sucks and the battery needs daily recharging, I finally figured out most of its bells and whistles and I like it.

I love my video iPod, but I'm wondering whether I'd shell out $500 to $600 bucks for a new one just because it has a phone and a touch screen.

Logic like this escapes me:

Dave Hamilton, co-publisher of an Apple news Web site called the Mac Observer, said most of the functions Jobs displayed are available on other products.

"I'd say about 80 percent of the features that were talked about today are available on a Treo," he said, "but Jobs is so good at standing on a stage and making you think he invented it."

Still, Hamilton said he'd trade in his Treo smart phone, made by Palm, "on day one" of the iPhone's release. Typically, he said, Apple makes a user interface that is so simple that "you don't have to wonder what your device can do."

On the other hand, the Apple TV announced today at $299 will be out in February and that I'd wait in line for.

The Apple TV syncs with iTunes just like an iPod, storing the data on an internal hard drive. It can also stream audio and video directly from the internet or from computers in a local network.

< Congressional War Power and the Iraq "Surge": Can Congress Restrict the Number of Troops in Iraq? | Abramoff Brings Down Another Official >

Poll

Will You Get an Apple iPhone?
No, my current phone works just fine. 38%
Yes, as soon as they are available. 23%
Yes, eventually 30%
No, this is all just sales hype 7%

Votes: 13
Results | Other Polls
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort: