The Candidates on Medical Marijuana
Granite Staters for Medical Marijuana grades the Presidential contenders on their medical marijuana stances:
Edwards has publicly stated that he would not change marijuana laws, and he favors the Justice Department's arresting patients and caregivers who defy federal law. (emphasis supplied)
....Responding to questions from Granite Staters for Medical Marijuana on July 7, 2003 on C-SPAN, Edwards reiterated his intention to set up a commission to study the therapeutic benefits of medical marijuana. When asked if he would jail seriously ill patients while his commission studies medical marijuana, Edwards responded "what'd you just say, there are raids?" However, when asked a week later on July 15, 2003 whether he would continue the current policy of jailing sick patients, he responded "the government has a responsibility to enforce the laws," echoing a comment he made six weeks earlier.
On May 29, 2003, Edwards was quoted in the San Francisco Chronicle, as saying,.....) "It's the job of the Justice Department to enforce the law as it presently exists."
Gephardt has switched positions and although he once voted against medical marijuana, he now says he'd support it. He gets a C-:
What Gephardt has said: When Granite Staters for Medical Marijuana's Linda Macia told Gephardt at a campaign stop on July 20, "I'm a patient and a medical marijuana advocate. I'm really ill, and I can't use drugs at all. I'm allergic to narcotics, I need your help. States' rights for sick people to--," Gephardt immediately said, "That's what I'm for...states' rights." When asked if he would sign federal legislation to allow seriously ill people to use medical marijuana with their doctors' approval, he responded, "Sure."
Note: We haven't seen a transcript confirming the above conversation.
John Kerry has backtracked the other way, earning a C grade:
Kerry previously said he favored federal legislation to allow people with cancer, AIDS, and other serious illnesses to have medical marijuana, with their doctors' approval. However, Kerry recently retreated from that stance, saying he wants to rely on a scientific review before he makes any decisions about protecting patients.
Joe Lieberman is another candidate who has switched positions. In 1999, he opposed medical marijuana. He's better on the issue this time around, but still earns only a D+:
Lieberman made his first public medical marijuana statement from the presidential campaign trail on July 6, 2003, telling Granite Staters for Medical Marijuana he would "probably" sign legislation to allow seriously ill people to use medical marijuana, with their doctors' approval. Lieberman went on to say, "I'm sympathetic."
Dean is the only candidate that has voted against a medical marijuana bill. He earns an F+. Why not an F? That's reserved for Bush:
Because of Dean's actions, Vermonters with AIDS, cancer, and other terrible illnesses still face arrest and jail under state law for using medical marijuana. Dean recently retreated from his earlier pledge to direct the FDA to study medical marijuana. His reversal and his actions have shown that medical marijuana patients can never trust him.
Bob Graham: C+
Graham would not sign federal legislation legalizing medical marijuana, though he would defer to states that protect patients with medical marijuana laws.... In February 2003, ABCNews.com reported, "Graham does not support legalizing marijuana. His spokeswoman said...Graham 'generally disfavors' federal pre-emption of state law."
The rest: Dennis Kucinich supports medical marijuana without reservation (A+). Carole Mosely Braun and Al Sharpton haven't yet addressed the issue.
|< ACLU Sues for Racial Profiling Data | Fox v. Al Franken: Text of Complaint >|