home
Hillary hate (5.00 / 0) (#42)
by dem08 on Mon Mar 31, 2008 at 11:54:50 AM EST
true, it should stop.

But a person would have to be a scholar to find those instances where this blog hasn't been pro-Hillary and anti-Obama.

Ann Althouse criticized a female blogger for dressing sexy when she had her photo taken with Bill Clinton, explaining :

"Third, the real target of this post is Bill Clinton. I think Clinton betrayed feminism (and I hate the way many feminists have given him a pass)(Althouse. September 16, 2006)."

Talk Left will even use an anti-Clinton person who is temporarily FOR Hillary to flog Obama. And any Democrat has to know that Althouse consistently expresses scorn for Democrats, progressives, young women, and praise for the war & Republicans. She and Instapundit are a joke in their "neutrality" and so-called Democratic Party membership.

I do not blame anyone for being negative.

I have a thesis, hardly original, that the nature of the Internet is to stir up easy hatreds.

However, a reader of this blog and nothing else,  would wonder why Obama ever was elected a district committeeman, much less is allowed to run for president.

Clearly, many on the so-called "left" --I say so-called because few progressives call for Single Payer Universal Coverage, Guarenteed Living Wage, etc. Obama doesn't either, but the old labels really don't apply anymore--leave one wondering why Hillary won anything and the farthest out there supporters, like Taylor Marsh and whoever her anti-Hillary counterparts are, why Obama isn't in jail).

And believe me, Mr. Llorens, I respect you, and so respectfully, I wonder why your distaste of Obama runs so deep. You say often that you "Favor" Obama as the most electable, and I know (like me) you wanted John Edwards, but reading this blog and being a life-long member of the Democratic Party, I think you describe Obama as deserving nobody's support for any office.

I know Jeralyn is a true blue Hillary supporter, and, respectfully, so is Talk Left.

[ Parent ]

Excuse me (5.00 / 3) (#71)
by Big Tent Democrat on Mon Mar 31, 2008 at 12:14:09 PM EST
I get so tired of these types of comments. Let's go through it:

"But a person would have to be a scholar to find those instances where this blog hasn't been pro-Hillary and anti-Obama."

There has NEVER been even a single post that attacked Barack Obama's character or commitment to progressive positions at this blog. EVER. Disagreeing with a pol is not hating them. That is the difference most Obama supporters seem unable to grasp.

Talk Left will even use an anti-Clinton person who is temporarily FOR Hillary to flog Obama. And any Democrat has to know that Althouse consistently expresses scorn for Democrats, progressives, young women, and praise for the war & Republicans. She and Instapundit are a joke in their "neutrality" and so-called Democratic Party membership.

Jeralyn Merrit has had a relationship of longstanding with both Althouse and Reynolds. She will engage them and agree with them sometimes and disagree with them in others. Anyone who has read me on both of those writers knows where I stand about them. But this is Jeralyn's blog and I do not trash her friends for no good reason. Did you address the SUBSTANCE of what Jeralyn wrote or merely attack the source of the argument?

I do not blame anyone for being negative.

When it comes to character attacks, I do.

I have a thesis, hardly original, that the nature of the Internet is to stir up easy hatreds. However, a reader of this blog and nothing else,  would wonder why Obama ever was elected a district committeeman, much less is allowed to run for president.

An ignorant reader of this blog would have that problem, or a cultist who can hear no criticism of the object of their worship without lashing out.

Clearly, many on the so-called "left" --I say so-called because few progressives call for Single Payer Universal Coverage, Guarenteed Living Wage, etc. Obama doesn't either, but the old labels really don't apply anymore--leave one wondering why Hillary won anything and the farthest out there supporters, like Taylor Marsh and whoever her anti-Hillary counterparts are, why Obama isn't in jail).

True dat.

And believe me, Mr. Llorens, I respect you, and so respectfully, I wonder why your distaste of Obama runs so deep. You say often that you "Favor" Obama as the most electable, and I know (like me) you wanted John Edwards, but reading this blog and being a life-long member of the Democratic Party, I think you describe Obama as deserving nobody's support for any office.

Then you have not read my posts on Obama, that span a near 3 year period, starting with my posts critical of him on the Supreme Court fights on Roberts and Alito. I am not going to explain myself to you. Your inability to even cite what my arguments are tells me all. You have not ENGAGED my writing at all.

You write well, but you say nothing imo.

I know Jeralyn is a true blue Hillary supporter, and, respectfully, so is Talk Left.

So what?

[ Parent ]

It's really not (5.00 / 1) (#118)
by Faust on Mon Mar 31, 2008 at 01:11:58 PM EST
There is defenitely some heavy handedness that goes on at this site BUT I've seen more generally civil discussion on this site than I've seen on most other blogs.

Look, things are really, really, really polarized in the left blogosphere right now. This site is also polarized, but it's far less polarized than most.

Lets say I asked you for some truly neutral and objective website where the discussion was disciplined and civil. Can you give me a good example?

And that's not a rhetorical question I really mean it, cause most sites at this point just gross me out. This one does too sometimes, but it seems better than average which is why I've started comming here regularly.

[ Parent ]

OpenLeft seems pretty civil and reasonable (none / 0) (#148)
by dotcommodity on Mon Mar 31, 2008 at 05:52:31 PM EST
to me, I think here and OpenLeft are the likeliest.

I prefer the um...furnishings at dailykos (the hotlists, the inconspicuous post design) etc, but it has been taken over by such a frenzy of testosteronefueled rage that no one there can think straight anymore/the commenters at MyDD, similar problem/other side...


[ Parent ]

Protesteth Much? (none / 0) (#109)
by mattt on Mon Mar 31, 2008 at 12:51:01 PM EST
There has NEVER been even a single post that attacked Barack Obama's character or commitment to progressive positions at this blog. EVER.

Some people might interpret accusations that a candidate makes "mendacious excuses" and has played "dirty tricks" in order to "disenfranchise" millions of voters, and who "attacks" a rival in a "harmful and divisive" manner out of "fear" as suggestions of character flaws.

At least, in progressive circles.  ;)

[ Parent ]

Only people (5.00 / 1) (#111)
by Big Tent Democrat on Mon Mar 31, 2008 at 12:55:23 PM EST
who have illusions about what politicians are.

Are you one of those?

[ Parent ]

If the shoe fits... nt (none / 0) (#138)
by FlaDemFem on Mon Mar 31, 2008 at 02:47:17 PM EST


[ Parent ]
You are suspended (none / 0) (#119)
by Big Tent Democrat on Mon Mar 31, 2008 at 01:14:32 PM EST
Do not commment further. And no, not because of this comment.

[ Parent ]
Should Be The Norm (5.00 / 4) (#91)
by squeaky on Mon Mar 31, 2008 at 12:33:06 PM EST
And believe me, Mr. Llorens, I respect you, and so respectfully, I wonder why your distaste of Obama runs so deep.
Seems to me that BTD is taking the position that every supporter should take. It only looks like distaste for the candidate and not his campaign mistakes and policies because everyone is showing nothing but uncritical cult adoration for their candidate, who can do no wrong.

Were things more normal we all would be making demands on both candidates to stop the BS and really win our support.

Not too much of that has been happening in either camp. It seems more like a redsox/yankees game than anything else.

[ Parent ]

Excellent analogy. (5.00 / 1) (#94)
by jeffinalabama on Mon Mar 31, 2008 at 12:35:30 PM EST
We should be demanding critically. thank goodness for the non-or weakly-aligned commentators who do examine issues, strategy and tactics without wearing rose-colored glasses.

[ Parent ]

  • Premium Ads

  • Blog Ads

  • Contribute To TalkLeft

    donate to TalkLeft